Unit 4: Ensuring rigour in mixed methods

Introduction

In previous units you explored the philosophical foundations of mixed methods and examined core methodological designs. Once you have chosen a design a critical question remains: how do you ensure your study is of high quality?

Rigour in mixed methods research concerns the actions and decisions made by researchers while conducting the study, as well as how researchers report on and describe the research process. These factors will determine the overall quality and credibility of the research. Combining quantitative and qualitative approaches brings unique challenges, particularly when integrating data, selecting representative versus purposive samples and managing conflicting findings. This unit will explore frameworks for ensuring and reporting rigour. It will also use real-world case studies to illuminate how research decisions relate to rigour and quality.

Unit learning outcomes

By the end of this unit, you will be able to:

  • define rigour in the context of mixed methods research
  • apply reporting frameworks (such as GRAMMS and the RMM framework) to evaluate or design mixed methods studies
  • address integration challenges, including managing conflicting findings and contradictory data
  • evaluate how purposive and random sampling operate together in mixed methods designs.

Estimated study time for this unit: 1 hour.

4.1 Designing for rigour: a starting scenario