2.1 Four ways of knowing

A photograph of three keyhole shapes cut from printed text, each with an arrow pointing in a different direction: left, straight up and right.

Researchers approach the world with different assumptions about what exists (ontology) and how we can know things (epistemology). These are the same concepts you met in Unit 1. These assumptions cluster into recognisable philosophical positions. You do not need to memorise these definitions but you should be able to recognise them when you see them in the literature.

Here are four such positions that you will encounter most often – they are not the only ones but they are the ones that shape how social science research is designed today:

  • Post-positivism holds that there is a real world out there, independent of our perceptions, but we can never know it with complete certainty. (The ‘post’ marks a step away from classical positivism, which assumed that careful science could deliver objective truth in full. Post-positivists accept that all observation is partial and theory-laden, but still believe that disciplined methods bring us closer to reality.) The best we can do is approximate reality through careful measurement, falsifiable hypotheses and statistical rigour. This position underpins most quantitative research. Post-positivists value objectivity, generalisability and statistical rigour.
  • Social constructionism holds that reality does not exist independently of human activity. Instead, reality is constructed by people and given meaning through social interaction. What counts as ‘knowledge’ is shaped by culture, language and context. This position underpins most qualitative research focused on meaning-making, lived experience and interpretation.
  • Critical realism distinguishes between three levels:
    • the ‘real’ – underlying structures and mechanisms that exist whether we observe them or not
    • the ‘actual’ – events that occur
    • the ‘empirical’ – what we can observe and measure.
  • Critical realists argue that we cannot directly see deep mechanisms but we can infer them from observable patterns. This position is useful when researchers want to understand not just what happens but what underlying structures cause it to happen.
  • Pragmatism takes a different stance altogether. Rather than committing to a single philosophical position, pragmatists ask: what works? They argue that the research question should drive method choice, not philosophical loyalty. If you need to know both ‘how many’ and ‘why’, then use both quantitative and qualitative methods. Pragmatism is the philosophical home of mixed methods research.

The following table compares the four positions.

Position View of reality View of knowledge Researcher role Typical methods
Post-positivism A real world exists independently We can approximate it through disciplined enquiry Detached, objective Surveys, experiments, statistical analysis
Social constructionism Reality is shaped through meaning-making and language Knowledge is co-produced in context Engaged, reflexive Interviews, ethnography, discourse analysis
Critical realism Real structures exist beneath observable events Knowledge bridges the real and the experienced Analytical, layered Mixed methods that move between mechanism and experience
Pragmatism Reality is what works for the question at hand Knowledge is judged by practical consequences Problem-driven Whatever methods best serve the question, often mixed

Activity 2.1: Recognising philosophical positions

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

a. 

Post-positivism


b. 

Social constructionism


c. 

Critical realism


d. 

Pragmatism


The correct answer is c.

Answer

The correct answer is critical realism. This statement distinguishes between observable effects and underlying mechanisms that cannot be directly measured but can be inferred.

a. 

Post-positivism


b. 

Social constructionism


c. 

Critical realism


d. 

Pragmatism


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The correct answer is social constructionism. This statement emphasises that meaning is constructed differently depending on social context and that understanding requires exploring how people make sense of concepts in their own terms.

a. 

Post-positivism


b. 

Social constructionism


c. 

Critical realism


d. 

Pragmatism


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is post-positivism. This statement reflects hypothesis testing, controlled comparison and the aim of establishing causal relationships through measurement.

a. 

Post-positivism


b. 

Social constructionism


c. 

Critical realism


d. 

Pragmatism


The correct answer is d.

Answer

The correct answer is pragmatism. This statement prioritises answering the research question fully, combining methods as needed rather than committing to a single approach.

2.2 Same question, four lenses