2.2 Same question, four lenses

To make these philosophical positions more concrete, consider how researchers from each tradition might approach the same question: ‘Why do students drop out of online courses?’

  • A post-positivist approach would measure observable behaviours and correlate them with outcomes. A researcher might analyse login frequency, assignment submission patterns and forum participation, and then use regression analysis to identify which factors predict dropout. The finding might be: ‘Students who log in fewer than three times per week are 2.4 times more likely to drop out.’
  • A social constructionist approach would explore what ‘dropping out’ means to students themselves. A researcher might conduct in-depth interviews with students who left, asking how they experienced the decision and what it meant in the context of their lives. The finding might be: ‘Students described dropping out as “giving up on a version of myself”. It was about identity, not just completion.’
  • A critical realist approach would look for underlying structures that generate observable patterns. A researcher might examine both quantitative patterns and qualitative accounts, asking what mechanisms explain both. The finding might be: ‘We cannot observe “financial anxiety” directly, but we can infer it from dropout spikes after funding cuts and from what students tell us about the pressures they faced.’
  • A pragmatist approach would ask what methods best answer the question, combining approaches as needed. A researcher might say: ‘We need to know both how many students are dropping out and why. Let us use learning analytics to identify patterns and interviews to understand what drives them.’

Notice that each approach asks a slightly different question and produces a different kind of knowledge. None is inherently ‘better’. They reveal different aspects of the same phenomenon.

Activity 2.2: Applying the four lenses

Timing: Allow approximately 15 minutes
By signing in and enrolling on this course you can view and complete all activities within the course, track your progress in My OpenLearn Create. and when you have completed a course, you can download and print a free Statement of Participation - which you can use to demonstrate your learning.

2.1 Four ways of knowing

2.3 The methodology continuum