2.4 Quantitative and qualitative: key differences

Before exploring how to combine approaches, it helps to understand what distinguishes them. The following table summarises key differences between quantitative and qualitative traditions.

DimensionQuantitativeQualitative
FocusMeasurement, magnitude, frequencyMeaning, experience, context
Data typeNumericalTextual, visual, observational
Sample sizeTypically largerTypically smaller
Sampling strategyUsually random or representative (also stratified, cluster, etc.)Usually purposive (also convenience, snowball, theoretical)
AnalysisStatisticalThematic, narrative, interpretive
GeneralisationTo populationsTo theory or concepts
Quality criteriaValidity, reliability, objectivityCredibility, transferability, reflexivity

These are generalisations. There are exceptions: some qualitative studies involve large samples; some quantitative studies are small-scale and exploratory. But the table captures the typical orientations of each tradition.

The key insight is that each approach answers different kinds of questions:

  • Quantitative methods are well suited to questions about what, how much and how many. They excel at examining relationships between variables, testing hypotheses and enabling comparison across groups.
  • Qualitative methods are well suited to questions about why, how and what does it mean. They excel at capturing context, exploring experience and understanding how people make sense of their worlds.

Neither is inherently better. They serve different purposes. The challenge – and the opportunity – lies in knowing when to use which, or when to combine them.

Activity 2.4: Matching questions to approaches

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

a. 

Quantitative


b. 

Qualitative


c. 

Both


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is quantitative. This question asks about proportion and completion rates, requiring numerical data and statistical analysis.

a. 

Quantitative


b. 

Qualitative


c. 

Both


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The correct answer is qualitative. This question asks about experience and meaning, requiring in-depth exploration of how students make sense of their transition.

a. 

Quantitative


b. 

Qualitative


c. 

Both


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is quantitative. This question asks about a relationship between two measurable variables, suited to correlation or regression analysis.

a. 

Quantitative


b. 

Qualitative


c. 

Both


The correct answer is c.

Answer

The correct answer is both. This question has two parts: identifying factors (quantitative) and understanding how students make sense of their decisions (qualitative). A mixed methods approach would address both.

2.3 The methodology continuum

2.5 Strengths and limitations