2.5 Strengths and limitations

Every research approach has strengths and limitations. Being honest about these helps you to make informed choices and strengthens your research design.

  • Quantitative strengths:
    • enable examination of relationships between variables
    • support hypothesis testing with statistical rigour
    • allow comparison across groups and contexts
    • have findings that can be generalised to wider populations (with appropriate sampling)
    • give results that are often seen as objective and credible by policymakers.
  • Quantitative limitations:
    • can miss contextual nuance and complexity
    • provide limited insight into ‘why’ and ‘how’
    • have a risk of oversimplifying complex phenomena
    • assume the constructs being measured are valid and meaningful
    • may impose researcher categories on participants.
  • Qualitative strengths:
    • capture real-world context and complexity
    • provide rich understanding of experience and meaning
    • explore emotions, beliefs and social processes
    • allow unexpected themes to emerge
    • give voice to participant perspectives.
  • Qualitative limitations:
    • has finding that are difficult to generalise beyond the sample
    • relies on samples that may be small and unrepresentative
    • use analysis that can be time-consuming and subjective
    • make it hard to assess relationships between variables statistically
    • may be seen as less credible by some audiences.

The promise of mixed methods is to bridge both traditions, drawing on the strengths of each while mitigating their limitations. Done well, mixed methods research can offer both statistical rigour and contextual depth, both breadth and richness.

But mixed methods is not a magic solution. It requires skills in both traditions. It takes more time and resources, and it must be done with genuine integration, not simply running a survey alongside some interviews and calling it ‘mixed’.

In Unit 3 you will explore the specific designs that make genuine integration possible. Unit 4 returns to this with three real-research case studies that illustrate where mixed methods adds value and where running two methods in parallel is not enough.

2.4 Quantitative and qualitative: key differences

2.6 Why pragmatism matters