2.6 Why pragmatism matters

A photograph of a toolbox containing an assortment of spanners, socket wrenches, and screwdrivers of different sizes.

Of the four philosophical positions introduced earlier, pragmatism deserves particular attention because it provides the foundation for mixed methods thinking.

Pragmatism originated in the work of American philosophers including Charles Sanders Peirce, William James and John Dewey. Its core principle is simple: judge ideas by their practical consequences. In research terms, this means choosing methods based on what will best answer your research question rather than on philosophical loyalty.

For mixed methods researchers, pragmatism is liberating. It offers permission to combine approaches without feeling that you are betraying a paradigm. You are not being philosophically inconsistent; you are being practical.

Pragmatism rests on several key principles:

  • The research question is paramount. Method choice follows from what you need to know, not from prior commitment to a tradition.
  • Multiple methods can address different aspects of a problem. If your question has quantitative and qualitative dimensions, use both.
  • Knowledge is provisional. What works in one context may not work in another. Findings are tentative and open to revision.
  • Practical outcomes matter. Research should contribute to understanding and action in the real world.

This does not mean that ‘anything goes’. Pragmatic researchers still need to justify their choices, demonstrate rigour and ensure coherence. But the justification centres on fitness for purpose: does this design help answer the research question?

Pragmatism is sometimes critiqued for being insufficiently philosophical: by privileging ‘what works’ it can sidestep important questions about whose definition of ‘works’ counts, and can shade into method-shopping if the researcher does not pause to articulate why they are combining what they are combining. The discipline pragmatism asks for is the discipline of justifying fitness for purpose explicitly.

If you find yourself drawn to pragmatism you are in good company: explicitly or implicitly, most mixed methods researchers operate from this stance.

2.5 Strengths and limitations