3.1 What makes a study ‘mixed methods’?

A photograph of a river flowing through a lush valley.

Not every study that uses surveys and interviews is a mixed methods study. The defining feature of mixed methods research is not simply the presence of multiple methods but the intentional integration of quantitative and qualitative approaches.

A study is considered mixed methods if it adopts quantitative and qualitative approaches in one or more of the following ways:

  • Research questions: You might have one question that is quantitative (‘What proportion of students withdraw before completion?’) and another that is qualitative (‘How do withdrawing students experience their decision to leave?’).
  • Data collection: You might use surveys to gather numerical data and interviews or focus groups to gather textual data.
  • Data types: You might work with both numerical data (test scores, response frequencies, scale ratings) and textual data (interview transcripts, open-ended responses, observation notes).
  • Data analysis: You might use statistical analysis for one strand and thematic analysis for another.

You do not need all four of these elements; having just one of them can make your study mixed methods. What matters is that the quantitative and qualitative components are brought together intentionally to address your research questions more fully than either approach could alone.

The key word is integration. If you run a survey and conduct some interviews but never bring the findings together, you have a multi-method study rather than a mixed methods study. True mixed methods research requires you to explain how and why the two strands inform each other.

Activity 3.1: Mixed methods or multi-method?

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

a. 

Mixed methods


b. 

Multi-method


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The correct answer is multi-method. Although two methods are used, there is no integration. The survey and interviews address different topics and the findings are not brought together.

a. 

Mixed methods


b. 

Multi-method


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is mixed methods. The quantitative findings (low satisfaction scores) directly inform the qualitative phase (interviews with those departments), and the qualitative findings are used to explain the quantitative patterns. This is integration.

a. 

Mixed methods


b. 

Multi-method


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is mixed methods. The qualitative phase (focus groups) is used to develop the quantitative instrument (questionnaire) and the quantitative phase tests the prevalence of qualitatively identified themes. This shows integration through development.

a. 

Mixed methods


b. 

Multi-method


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The correct answer is multi-method. Despite collecting both types of data, the lack of comparison or connection means there is no integration. The study uses multiple methods but does not mix them.

3.2 The iterative research cycle