4.1 Designing for rigour: a starting scenario

Ensuring rigour begins at the design phase. A rigorous study requires:

  • a clear rationale for mixing methods
  • well-defined research questions for both strands
  • explicit plans for integration
  • a deliberate sequence for data collection and analysis
  • transparency about all of these decisions in how the study is reported.

Let us start with a practical scenario.

Activity 4.1: Designing a mixed methods response

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

Read the following research scenario:

Many female colleagues at your faculty are leaving their jobs shortly after they are employed. There is a new director in place. Similar observations are made in other faculties where there were no changes in leadership.

Based on this scenario how would you design a mixed methods study to investigate this issue? Consider the following questions:

  • What are your research questions?
  • What method of data collection are you going to use for each question?
  • When are you going to collect your data (sequentially, concurrently) and why?
To use this interactive functionality a free OU account is required. Sign in or register.
Interactive feature not available in single page view (see it in standard view).

Discussion

There are multiple rigorous ways to design this study but a strong approach might be an explanatory sequential design.

  • Phase 1 (quantitative): You might start by analysing human resources data across all faculties to measure the exact retention rates, demographics and timing of departures to verify the scale and specific patterns of the problem.
  • Phase 2 (qualitative): You would then conduct in-depth exit interviews with the female colleagues who recently left to explore their lived experiences and reasons for leaving.
  • Timing: Sequential (QUAN → qual). You collect the quantitative data first to establish the pattern and use the qualitative data to explain the ‘why’ behind the numbers.

4.2 Managing conflicting findings