Skip to content
Health, Sports & Psychology

Is mental health care a family affair?

Updated Friday 15th March 2013

Lecturer in Mental Health Nursing John Rowe explores the concept of carer-centred practice.

A collection of family members Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Solarseven | Dreamstime.com Relationships between professionals and the people in their care are fundamental to mental health practice. When care was largely given in institutional settings, these relationships needed to be primarily between professionals and patients, but modern service provision is increasingly focused on community settings, where half of mental health care now takes place. You can read more about this in an article published by Professor Wai Tong Chien and others.

According to the Office for National Statistics there are 1.5 million people caring for a relative or friend with a mental health problem or dementia. It is now not enough for relationships to be only between professionals and patients; they need to be built and maintained across a wider range of individual boundaries, with an increasing emphasis on the role of family caregivers in supporting recovery for people in mental distress. In particular, more responsibility for psychosocial care has been placed on family carers. Indeed, David Jones, an academic who carried out 40 in-depth interviews with informal carers, implied that following the accelerated move from institutional to community-based care in the 1980s there was an expectation that families would fill the care vacuum.

What about the family’s rights?

In this context then, how can mental health professionals provide care that balances the rights of the family with those of the service user? I applied the principles outlined by Professor Jacques P. Thiroux in 2005 as a conceptual framework to explore professionals’ relationship with family carers. These basic principles are found in many ethical systems and can be applied within the context of mental health care.

  • The value of life: Family carers should also have their life and the value of that life respected, not just be treated as a means to care for their relative.
  • Goodness or rightness: In promoting goodness, consideration should be given to what is good for family carers. Keeping them informed about care decisions is good, as not to do so could potentially expose them to psychological and emotional distress.
  • Truth-telling or honesty: In any relationship, truth-telling or honesty is vital to meaningful communication. Good relationships are based on mutual trust, and communication should be as open and honest as possible.
  • Justice or fairness: Fair practice means that people share equal opportunities. Depriving families of key information denies them the opportunity to be involved in care planning and decision making on issues that can have profound implications for them.
  • Individual freedom: In its narrow sense individual freedom or autonomy is about being in control of oneself, and independence; but if health care ethics is about people and the relationships between them, then there are limitations to individual freedom. These limitations should be established by the other four principles discussed above.

Relationships and engagement

Despite initiatives and legislation, more can be done to improve the experience of family carers. Caring for a relative with severe mental health problems is a distinct and unique experience and a steep learning curve for which few people are prepared. The relationship and engagement between families and professionals is therefore of great importance.

When I conducted a systematic literature review on the relationship and engagement between families and mental health professionals, I identified four key themes:

  • The distinct and personal nature of family caring. Carers in mental health had different needs to carers of relatives with physical health problems.
  • Potentially effective family caring. This can be summarised as being involved, included and a source of expert knowledge.
  • Barriers and hindrances to effective caring. These included: being seen as part of the problem, being taken for granted and isolated. Carers have been trapped in the confines of their caring role and expected to cope.
  • Ways to overcome barriers and hindrances. Barriers to effective care that involves family carers can be overcome by taking account of family carers’ rights and responsibilities. This means listening to and taking seriously what they have to say. Providing timely support and assistance demonstrates to families that their responsibilities are recognised, and that they have a valued part to play in decision-making and treatment approaches. It would also be to their advantage to learn more about mental health and highlight any cultural diversity elements to professionals.

In essence barriers can be overcome through good practice by professionals and by carers making use of their strengths. Mutual obligations which drive improvements in relationships and engagement between families and services have been proposed as a covenant between mental health services and family carers.

Cutout paper chain family with the protection of cupped hands, concept for security and care Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Flynt | Dreamstime.com

A covenantal relationship

A covenantal relationship would clarify what professionals expect of family carers. Good faith and fair dealing are central for this to work. Family carers’ good faith can be demonstrated through involvement in their relative’s care, helping with recovery plans and accepting that they do not need to know everything about their relative.

Mental health services might reciprocate through fair dealing: being empathetic, promoting engagement and co-operative relationships, and recognising the difficulties that might arise for families. However, a covenant between families and services would mean adopting carer-centred practice.

 

Towards carer-centred practice

Key characteristics of carer-centred practice emerge from overcoming barriers and achieving effective relationships and engagement with family carers. This is possible by:

  • Being carer aware and identifying family carers as soon as possible.
  • Developing relationships with carers to work in partnership with them.
  • Resisting assumptions that carers and service users have shared interests and needs.
  • Encouraging family support in the care of their relative at a formal level, for instance in treatment approaches or attending review meetings, and less formally such as by being including in research design.
  • Making use of family carer expertise.

Carer-centred practice is a recognised priority for research that builds on relational practice. It complements care given to service users and is not an alternative competitive demand on services. However, primarily, carer-centred practice recognises that mental health care is a family affair.

Further reading

  • Chien, W.T., Chan, S., Morrissey, J. et al (2005) ‘Effectiveness of a mutual support group for families of patients with schizophrenia’, Journal of Advanced Nursing, 51, pp.595-608.
  • Jones, D.W. (2001) ‘Myths, Madness and the Family: The Impact of Mental Illness on Families’, Palgrave, Basingstoke.
  • Rowe, J. (2010) ‘Information disclosure to family caregivers: Applying Thiroux’s framework’, Nursing Ethics, 17 (4), pp.435-444.
  • Rowe, J. (2012a) ‘Great expectations: a systematic review of the literature on the role of family carers in severe mental illness, and their relationships and engagement with professionals’, Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 19, pp.70-82.
  • Rowe, J. (2012b) ‘A covenant between mental health services and family carers’, Mental Health Practice, 16 (2), pp.22-23.
 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Green care: contact with nature can improve mental health article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Green care: contact with nature can improve mental health

Can being outside gardening improve our wellbeing? Discover three factors that account for the positive effects of 'green care'.

Article
Caring: A Family Affair Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Caring: A Family Affair

Care is needed at all stages of life. This free course, Caring: A family affair, makes care in the family its focus because the overwhelming majority of care, including health care, is supplied in families, much of it in private, much of it unnoticed and unremarked upon. The meaning of the term (informal carer) and the word (care) itself are explored.

Free course
8 hrs
article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Improving the everyday lives of carers

Many carers feel undervalued by society and that they are having to ‘go it alone’. The European Funded DISCOVER project, which included a team from the Open University led by Dr Verina Waights, have developed a website to support carers through helping them to use digital technologies and get online. 

Article
A Support Net: Can you help someone in need? Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license activity icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

A Support Net: Can you help someone in need?

All of us will experience personal challenges, but could you make a positive impact on someone's life? Try our wellbeing interactive 'A Support Net' to see if you can help four people.

Activity
Making sense of mental health problems free course icon Level 2 icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Making sense of mental health problems

Over the past century there has been a radical shift in responses to people who experience mental health problems. In this free course, Making sense of mental health problems, you will learn about how key perspectives in the field have made sense of mental health problems. By directly relating key perspectives to a case study, you will reflect on how the medical perspective, psychological perspective and social need perspective come to make sense of mental ill-health.

Free course
10 hrs
Exploring family health Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Iakov Filimonov/Dreamstime.com free course icon Level 1 icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Exploring family health

How can families support healthy living and cope with illness? This free course, Exploring family health, will provide an understanding of what is meant by socialisation. You will recognise how a family can learn and support good and poor health behaviours alongside government interventions, such as the 5 A DAY strategy. Identification of people with Alzheimer's disease is steadily increasing and you will consider key features and research. Caring within a family will be considered through reading about Sheila who cares for her husband and son. Finally, the course will look at the plight of young carers, often hidden from view, and losing part of their childhood due to their caring responsibilities.

Free course
8 hrs
Can we get to a world without suicide? Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Free-Photos article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Can we get to a world without suicide?

After his son’s suicide aged 18, Steve Mallen sees the world differently. Along with a growing number of mental health experts, he wants to reduce the rate of suicide across the world, and is aiming for zero. Simon Usborne finds out more.

Article
India-Pakistan: post-partition traumas Creative commons image Icon Ktims at the English language Wikipedia [GFDL (http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html) or CC-BY-SA-3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/)], via Wikimedia Commons under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

India-Pakistan: post-partition traumas

What are the impacts of partition on the people affected by it? Here we look at trauma, identity politics and escalation of violence in India and Pakistan.

Article
Why is the media still fascinated by Brady and Hindley's crimes? Creative commons image Icon David Brown under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Why is the media still fascinated by Brady and Hindley's crimes?

Half a century on, the Moors Murders remain a fixed point of fascination and horror for the UK media. Two Manchester-based academics explain why.

Article