The Italian Patient: Health care in Renaissance Italy

Updated Thursday 1st September 2005

Were Renaissance hospitals hell-holes? John Henderson finds similarities to today's health care, and Katherine Park shows that autopsies were often performed.

Picture of Benivieni Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team

There was a vast array of health care options because the practice of medicine was not seen as an exclusively professional business - anyone could do it.

Physicians with university degrees treated internal illnesses.

Surgeons, who learnt by apprenticeship, treated wounds, fractures and external illnesses.

Apothecaries made and sold medicines, barber surgeons bled patients and pulled teeth.

Herbal remedies were administered by those who had learned the tradition orally - often harnessing the powers of natural magic. Some were licensed to practice their skill, many were not.

Women were found amongst the licensed practitioners.

They were not allowed to go to university, but a physician might teach his wife or daughter, who could then practice on licence. Large numbers of women were in fact involved in healing - making medicines, setting bones and treating small wounds - but nearly always without the status of men.

95% of unlicensed practitioners were women. Increasingly, unlicensed women found themselves on the edge of society, and towards the end of the Renaissance more and more were put on trial for practising witchcraft.

Evidence

View of Florence Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission Foucault called Renaissance hospitals "antechambers of death", and historians have argued that the Christian Church stunted the growth of medical science.

New research by John Henderson overturns this view. He reveals what it was like to be an 'Italian Patient' and shows that there are remarkable similarities to health care provisions today. Katherine Park has shown that at the same time the practice of autopsy was in full swing with the sanction of the Church.

In the late medieval period hospitals were built in Florence as charitable institutions, to provide food, lodging, spiritual fulfilment and medical care for the poor. During the Renaissance hospitals came increasingly to specialise; some continued to look after the poor, others became orphanages. Santa Maria Nuova looked after the sick poor.

Thinking History

What do Renaissance hospitals tell us about? Not just about medicine, but also about concepts of the body to which that medicine was applied, the destiny of the soul (should the medicine not work), the priorities of the society from which the funds for the treatment were forthcoming (or extracted).

But the people who documented the work at the Florentine hospital of Santa Maria Nuova were not writing for us, a curious posterity; we can delight in the astonishing completeness of their records but must still be very careful about how we interpret them.

In the other sections we will look at two pieces of evidence and invite you to have a go at analysing them critically.

We can begin to answer the questions posed here from the evidence in the programmes; but answers tend to prompt more questions and you may like to pursue these through the books below or with a course on the Renaissance with The Open University.

The full story

Further reading

Piety and Charity in late Medieval Florence

J. Henderson (University of Chicago Press, 1997)

The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: a Medical History from antiquity to the present

R. Porter (Harper Collins, 1997)

The Body Emblazoned: Dissection and the Human Body in Renaissance Culture

J. Sawday (Routledge, 1995)

Doctors and Medicine in Early Renaissance Florence

K. Park (Princeton, 1985)

Our experts

Meet the team who helped shape our exploration of health in Renaissance Italy

Dr John Henderson

Dr John Henderson Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission

John Henderson fell in love with the city of Florence at the age of 18. The beauty of the city, its extraordinary collections of art, the friendliness of the people and excellent food and drink, have meant that first impressions have lasted. He not only lived in Florence for over three years, but returns every summer to do research.

His work on Florentine hospitals led him to co-found the International Network for the History of Hospitals in 1995. He has been a member of the Scientific Committee of the Commune of Florence initiative 'La citt e la salute' which organised a major exhibition in the Palazzo Vecchio on the history of Florentine hospitals.

He is now a member of two more committees in Florence, the first organising a long-term research project on the history of the Hospital of Santa Maria Nuova; the second is as one of the founding editors of an Italian journal about the history of medicine, Medicina e Storia.

The research featured in The Italian Patient is being written up by John to be published by Yale University Press under the title The Renaissance Hospital in Florence and Italy. He lectures at the University of Cambridge on subjects such as the 'Black Death in Medieval Italy' and 'Society and Culture in Renaissance Italy'.

 

Professor Katherine Park Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission Professor Katherine Park

Katherine Park initially developed an interest in the history of medicine because her own sister is autistic. It was this that motivated her to look at changing attitudes to illness through history.

Her more recent research has focused on the history of the body, gender, and sexuality. Among her many awards Katherine received the Walter Channing Cabot Fellowship, presented in recognition of scholarly eminence in literature, history, or art.

For her book, Wonders and the Order of Nature she won the Pfizer Prize of the History of Science Society for best book on the history of science published in English in the preceding three years.

Katherine is currently writing up the research on dissection featured in The Italian patient and for publication as Visible Women: Gender, Generation, and the Origins of Human Dissection. She's also currently co-editing (with Lorraine Daston) volume three of The Cambridge History of Science. She's Chair of Women's Studies at Harvard University.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

The mystery of The Arnolfini Marriage Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

History & The Arts 

The mystery of The Arnolfini Marriage

Introducing the secret behind an enigmatic masterpiece.

Article
Origin Day lecture: Randal Keynes response Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Randal Keynes video icon

History & The Arts 

Origin Day lecture: Randal Keynes response

Randal Keynes offers his response to EO Wilson's lecture.

Video
10 mins
A short history of the early days of artificial intelligence Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Archive.org article icon

History & The Arts 

A short history of the early days of artificial intelligence

Artificial Intelligence seems very much of our time - but as Jessica Riskin explains, history records many attempts to create machines that think.

Article
Origin Day Lecture: Audience Question Three Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: British Council video icon

History & The Arts 

Origin Day Lecture: Audience Question Three

In 50 million years' time is the impact of modern man on biodiversity going to look significantly different from the meteorite strike which we believe wiped out the dinosaurs?

Video
5 mins
Extract from Origin Of Species Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

Extract from Origin Of Species

In 1859 Darwin published a book that was to change the way in which we all viewed the world. "On the Origin of Species" was to bring this quiet man a fame that he was to shun for the rest of his days. The theory of natural selection deals with the way in which species are selected to survive by nature. Any advantage, be it the right shaped beak or a long neck, will tend to be developed by the evolutionary process. Hence the giraffe or the kangaroo or even humans have evolved a variety of ways and means that give them an advantage over other species. The following is an extract from a chapter in Darwin’s book entitled: "Natural selection".

Article
History of The Transit of Venus Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission article icon

History & The Arts 

History of The Transit of Venus

There are no records of astronomers observing the Transit of Venus until the 17th century. Professor David W Hughes picks up the story

Article
Transistors and thermionic valves Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

Transistors and thermionic valves

Without the valve and the transistor there would be no radio, no television and no computers. How did these vital inventions come about?

Article
Darwin crosses the Sierra de la Ventana Creative commons image Icon raul senzacqua under CC-BY-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

History & The Arts 

Darwin crosses the Sierra de la Ventana

As part of his journey towards Buenos Aires, Darwin crosses the Sierra de la Ventana - but finds the vista less than thrilling.

Article
Bridges and Buildings: The structures of the Industrial Revolution Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

History & The Arts 

Bridges and Buildings: The structures of the Industrial Revolution

Dr Peter Lewis takes a look at the impact that the industrial revolution had on bridge building.

Article