Airlines face the Prisoner's Dilemma

Updated Monday 9th October 2006

If companies collude with each other, how can they minimise the damage to themselves once they're caught out?

Markets such as the airline industry, where there are a few large players, are known as oligopolies. In such markets, the limited number of players mean there’s an opportunity – and temptation – for firms to formally or informally agree to increase the prices of the services they provide, operating what is known as a cartel. Game theory can help us understand this behaviour, and the choices made.

The Prisoner’s Dilemma is a classic game devised in the late 1940s by John Nash (the subject of the movie A Beautiful Mind) to teach the conflict between group and individual rationality. Consider a crime drama where two partners are arrested. Both are being separately interrogated by a clever inspector who offers them this deal:

  • If one implicates the other, he may get parole while the other will get 20 years in jail
  • If neither implicates the other, both will get two years in jail
  • If both implicate each other, both will get ten years in jail

Given the consequences of the different choices, and to minimise their individual punishment, both partners choose to implicate the other and end up getting ten years in jail.

Prisoner’s Dilemma is applicable to many walks of life. Consider sports. Imagine a contest with two players. Each player’s in a dilemma about whether to take a performance-enhancing drug. Rationally, each player may think like this:

  • If I don’t take it and the other one takes it, this increases my chances of losing
  • If I take it and the other one doesn’t take it, this increases my chances of winning
  • If both of us take it, then at least I’m not disadvantaged

Thinking like this each player ends up taking the drug!

There's an incentive to any player in the game to blow the whistle

However, cartels aren’t a recent phenomenon. Adam Smith, the father of modern economics, warned of such possibilities over three hundred years ago in Wealth of Nations, when he wrote,

"people of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices".

Fearing this, many countries have created regulators to curb anti-competitive behaviour. But would Smith have approved of regulatory interventions to prevent anti-competitive practices in a free market? The answer would appear to be no, as he went on to say,

"it is impossible indeed to prevent such meetings, by any law which either could be executed, or would be consistent with liberty and justice".

Now, let’s get back to the recent story about airlines. It is alleged that British Airways (BA) and Virgin conspired to increase the prices of passenger tickets, by making almost parallel increases in fuel surcharges over the last few years. Virgin reported this to the Office of Fair Trading (OFT), a government agency in charge of curbing anti-competitive practices.

Let’s look at this case from the perspective of game theory. The Enterprise Act 2000 provides that any party involved in cartels can become an informer to the OFT and cooperate with the investigating agency for possible ‘immunity from prosecution’. This provides an incentive to any player in the game to blow the whistle on another player.

Whether Virgin and BA cooperated and earned huge profits, or not, won’t be known until the full report of the ongoing enquiry is published. But, by becoming an informer before BA could do so, Virgin has increased its chances of going scot free by playing the game smartly. It appears it's one more smart move from Richard Branson and co!

Find out more

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

The Prisoner's Dilemma in detail Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

The Prisoner's Dilemma in detail

Sean Crawford explains the Prisoner's dilemma.

Article

History & The Arts 

360 Degrees of Separation

How does Surrealism relate to Freud? What does Freud have to do with the Prisoner's dilemma? Josie Long takes you on a whistle-stop tour and finds the connections between Surrealism, Psychoanalysis, Game Theory, Nuclear Fission and microbes that may have played a key role in the origins of life.

Video
10 mins
The Prisoner's Dilemma Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

The Prisoner's Dilemma

The Prisoner’s Dilemma is a classic example of games theory, an area of mathematics whose foundations were laid down by John Nash.

Article
Do public works work? Using government spending to beat a recession Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: photos.com video icon

Money & Business 

Do public works work? Using government spending to beat a recession

James Caan and an expert panel discuss government plans for public works projects - can we dig our way out of recession?

Video
5 mins
The problem with pubs Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: photos.com video icon

Money & Business 

The problem with pubs

Is you local shutting down? City and Business Editor of The Publican Hamish Champ talks to us about the issues facing pubs across the UK today.

Video
5 mins
Implementing the project Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Money & Business 

Implementing the project

Day-to-day monitoring of a project is essential to ensure that work is progressing according to the plan, and it will often be necessary to review and revise the plan as circumstances change. This free course, Implementing the project, will introduce some of the key techniques that help managers to monitor and control projects, and consider what approaches work best in particular circumstances.

Free course
8 hrs
The life sciences industry: An introduction Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Money & Business 

The life sciences industry: An introduction

This free course, The life sciences industry: An introduction, covers the emergence of the life sciences sector out of its precursor the pharmaceutical industry. After examining some historical perspectives, the course uses case studies to look at developments in the science, business and, primarily, management strategies used in life sciences. It also briefly considers the place of life sciences in the wider story of health provision. This introductory course will be of interest to managers in the life sciences sector and to the general reader.

Free course
6 hrs
10 years of The Bottom Line Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Money & Business 

10 years of The Bottom Line

As The Bottom Line celebrates its 10 year anniversary, we look back over the past decade in the world of business.

Article
How did United Airlines get their PR response so wrong? Creative commons image Icon ERIC SALARD under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license video icon

Money & Business 

How did United Airlines get their PR response so wrong?

After a passenger was filmed being dragged from a plane, it felt like United were being dragged against their will into apologising. Morgen Witzel explains how the airline blundered.

Video
5 mins