Skip to content

Top predators and ecosystems

Updated Tuesday 10th December 2013

Ecosystems may not be as simple as you think. Find out what happens when a top predator is removed from one. 

Harp seal (Pagophilus groenlandicus) Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Aleksandrn | Harp seal Here’s a familiar story. Humans systematically remove animals from natural populations, either in order to exploit what is seen as a resource, or to cull animals seen as a threat. When the cod stocks of the east coast of Canada started to decline in the 1980s there were calls to cull the harp seal and grey seal populations along the coast. It was said that the seals were taking cod and that culling the seals would increase the yield of the fishery. In other words, it wasn’t so much the decline in overall population that was stimulating the demand for a cull; it was the idea that if the seals took less, the fishery could take more.

Ecosystems don’t work in this simple manner. Seals will take other fish, too - maybe a lower predator that feeds on small cod. It is a question of establishing the food web that makes up an ecosystem and this may be very complicated, as the food web for the Benguela ecosystem off the coast of South Africa below demonstrates (Figure 3, p.637). Here, there are seals feeding on fish that are exploited commercially, but detailed modelling suggests that a cull of the seals would have a detrimental effect on yields from the exploited species. A food web for the Benguela ecosystem Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: 1999-2013 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Select image to view original version in more detail With a system as complicated as this you could not determine what might happen if you made a change, by doing an experiment. Only modelling offers a practical approach in this case.

The effects of change on some ecosystems have been studied experimentally, although modelling is still needed to predict long-term effects. These are systems in which top predators have been eliminated. A much studied example is in Yellowstone National Park. The top predator is the grey wolf but it was no longer present in the park after the 1920s. Wolves prey on elk all the year round, but once the pressure from predation was removed, the elk population enlarged and the principal cause of mortality was severe winters. Mortality became seasonal. Without wolves, the principal beneficiaries were scavengers, particularly those that could get to the carcasses even in the depths of winter.

In the last 60 years, winters in Yellowstone have been getting shorter. This change has an impact on the elk since fewer elk die and the period over which weather-linked deaths occur is a smaller proportion of the year. Scavengers have less time for feeding on elk carcasses and so probably moved to different prey at other times of the year. You can imagine that change spreading out across the whole ecosystem. In 1995, wolves were re-introduced and once again elk mortality was spread across the whole year.

As you can imagine, Yellowstone National Park is well-studied. In one study, 240 carcasses of elks killed by wolves were observed to see what which animals were feeding on them. Gray Wolf Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Alain | Grey wolf This was part of a study on the effects of climate change and one very interesting prediction that came out of the study was that the wolves would buffer the effect of warmer winters by maintaining a supply of carcasses for the scavengers all the year round. The decline in weather-related mortality of elks would be offset by wolf predation. So, regardless of whether the planet is warming or cooling, the presence of wolves will enable scavengers to adapt to the effect of global change, over a longer timescale.

Top predators are an integral part of an ecosystem, but recent work has highlighted their potential for ecosystem restoration and for providing ecosystems with resilience to changes in climate. Reintroduction of top predators is not easy or always desirable.



Further reading

Ritchie, E.G., Elmhagen, B., Glen, A.S., Letnic, M., Ludwig, G. and McDonald, R.A. (2012) 'Ecosystem restoration with teeth: what role for predators', Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 27 (5), pp.265-271.


For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

String of sausages lichen Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC audio icon

Nature & Environment 

String of sausages lichen

Could this unusually named lichen be making a comeback?

10 mins
Ancestors on the beach Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Nature & Environment 

Ancestors on the beach

Patricia Ash explores the evidence of our ancestors on the coast – and how they lived their lives

The desert tortoise without the hare Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC [Photographer: Howard Stableford] audio icon

Nature & Environment 

The desert tortoise without the hare

How important are desert tortoises to the desert ecosystem? The Saving Species team talks to biologist Kimberley Field in this extended interview

15 mins
Studying mammals: Return to the water Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Nature & Environment 

Studying mammals: Return to the water

Some of the most unusual and versatile of all the mammals are the groups that live, feed and reproduce underwater. In this free course, Studying mammals: Return to the water, we will see how these formerly land-based mammals adapted to a return to the water, discussing such challenges as breathing, movement and communication. This is the seventh course in the Studying mammals series.

Free course
10 hrs
Invaders - An Introduction Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission article icon

Nature & Environment 

Invaders - An Introduction

The impact that the invasion of exotic plants and animals has had on the British Isles - introduction

Brownfield land: barren, or buzzing? Creative commons image Icon Photo by Hugh Venables / CC BY-SA 2.0 under Creative-Commons license audio icon

Nature & Environment 

Brownfield land: barren, or buzzing?

Pioneering environmentalist Chris Baines discusses the value of brownfield sites for wildlife

5 mins
Evolution - right here, right now Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission article icon

Nature & Environment 

Evolution - right here, right now

OU academic Valerie Jeffries explores the evidence that evolution is all around us. What do you think? Join the debate.

article icon

Nature & Environment 

A bad taste in the mouth is more than a phrase

The Breaking Science team explored research suggesting that 'bad taste in my mouth' is more than a metaphor

The surprising link between brain and pelvis Creative commons image Icon bixentro under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Nature & Environment 

The surprising link between brain and pelvis

What do our ancestors tell us about the relationship between pelvis size and brain development?