Skip to content

Holding back the tide

Updated Tuesday 7th September 2004

Managing flooding might prove more effective than a losing battle with the tides, explains Paul Brown

Flood protection wall Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team

At last the lesson King Canute tried to teach his subjects, that no man can turn back the tide, has finally sunk in. After 1,000 years of building sea walls and grabbing more and more land from the sea, carefully built sea defences are, in many places, beginning to be deliberately destroyed.

Although, at £400 million a year, more is still being spent on 20,000 miles of flood defences than at any time in history, the Environment Agency and the Government have accepted that all of Britain cannot be protected from the sea. As the East and South of England sink below sea level at increasing speed, the plan is that more and more low lying land will be abandoned. Experiments have shown that a sea wall costs £5,000 a metre to build and maintain.

However, retreating 80 metres inland and allowing a salt marsh to form breaks up the tide and waves, so the new sea wall sheltering behind it costs only £400 a metre to do the same job. The problem for the Environment Agency and the Government is that the sea is rising all the time, and the natural salt marshes are being washed away, leaving more and more sea wall exposed.

The problem is made worse by two factors. The South-East continues to tilt into the sea as a result of the "rebound" of the Scottish mountains from the last Ice Age, and the sea level is rising every year because global warming is both melting glaciers and causing thermal expansion of the oceans.

Sea levels may rise by a metre (about 39 inches) in some places in fifty years. Add to that the effect of higher tides and large areas vulnerable to a storm surge. There is no suggestion that urban areas will be abandoned, but like Canvey Island in the Thames Estuary, "drowned" in the 1953 flood, they may become islands surrounded by sea defences while agricultural land is used as a buffer against floods.

The policy of pushing back the sea began in Roman times, when the first defence banks were built in the Wash. The reversal of this practice is controversial. Farmers used to the Government building and paying for sea defences to protect their land are reluctant to see arable land, farmed for generations, revert to salt marsh.

But the need to save money and concentrate on averting the threat to towns has found support in the scientific community and in the British love of the natural world. Salt marshes and inter-tidal mud flats in estuaries support two million wildfowl and wading birds in winter and are home to rare and specialised plants and animals. Coastal wetlands provide a vital source of food and shelter for commercially exploited fish and shellfish. The mud and plants also digest pesticides, nutrients and other pollutants that would otherwise damage the environment. But they all are fast disappearing.

In Essex one of the first projects to let the sea back onto farmland, at Abbots Hall at Salcott Creek, took three years to gain acceptance. It needed 32 separate planning permissions and licences, as well as the consent of the farmers and the oyster fishermen who feared mud would interfere with their oyster beds.

Elliot Morley, the Minister responsible for sea defences, interviewed on the BBC/Open University TV programme Flooded Britain concedes the issue is so sensitive that he calls the process not coastal retreat but "managed realignment." He believes that the future will see "unsustainable defences being replaced by managed realignment." Farmers will graze cattle on salt marshes and sell premium local beef, rather than grow wheat, and Essex will become a Mecca for tourists looking at the wildlife, he claims.

The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) say these projects will be needed on a large scale if existing salt marshes are to be replaced as the sea drowns existing ones and washes them away. Already there are schemes to replace salt marches, four in Essex, one each in Devon and Somerset and in the Cromarty Firth in Scotland. Six more are planned. But the RSPB and the Environment Agency estimate 10,000 hectares of farmland will have to be abandoned to the sea in the next 15 years to keep pace with the encroaching tide.

This article was originally published in 2003

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Animal life in the ice Creative commons image Icon Billyboy under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Animal life in the ice

There is harsh living to be had in the arctic and antarctic - explore the life of animals who live in the ice.

Article
OU on the BBC: Coast - About the 2007 series Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: Coast - About the 2007 series

Coast returns for a third series, with new adventures that involve journeys around the most extreme parts of the British Isles.

Article
Recipe: Sea bass in salt Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team activity icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Recipe: Sea bass in salt

Try out our recipe from the Ever Wondered About Food series

Activity
Landscape Mysteries - Programme 4: Secrets of the Flood Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Landscape Mysteries - Programme 4: Secrets of the Flood

Britain is tilting and, as a result sea levels are falling in Scotland and rising in the south.

Article
An Island Race? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

An Island Race?

"Are people who live on islands different in some significant way from those who inhabit the 'mainland'?" asks Nigel Clark

Article
Breathing easy in India Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Bob Spicer article icon

Nature & Environment 

Breathing easy in India

In spite of the chaos and the variety of vehicles, India may be greener than the UK when it comes to traffic pollution.

Article
Understanding the environment: Learning and communication free course icon Level 2 icon

Nature & Environment 

Understanding the environment: Learning and communication

There is increasing recognition that the reductionist mindset that is currently dominating society, rooted in unlimited economic growth unperceptive to its social and environmental impact, cannot resolve the converging environmental, social and economic crises we now face. The primary aim of this free course, Understanding the environment: Learning and communication, is to encourage the shift away from reductionist and human centred thinking towards a holistic and ecological worldview.

Free course
12 hrs
Allotments: the Russian way Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: M E Dodd article icon

Nature & Environment 

Allotments: the Russian way

Mike Dodd heads East and is impressed with Russian allotments.

Article
The climateprediction.net story Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Nature & Environment 

The climateprediction.net story

As the results are announced, we look back at the rollercoaster ride of the experiment. Bob Spicer tells the climateprediction.net story

Article