Skip to content
Society, Politics & Law

Methods in Motion: With the mothers of Munich & Birmingham

Updated Tuesday 29th November 2016

Dr Agata Lisiak, Visiting Fellow at The Open University, explores the fast-changing world of research into migration and belonging.

Munich panorama Creative commons image Icon deep_schismic under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license

Migration was one of the most heatedly debated issues throughout the EU referendum campaign. In the months leading up to Brexit, European and non-European migrants alike were repeatedly named and shamed. In the aftermath, they report experiencing a mixture of anxiety, fear and shock. The Leave campaign drew significantly on an anti-immigrant rhetoric of ‘waves’ and ‘swarms’ threatening to take over Great Britain, scaremongering ‘breaking point’ images, and big numbers taken from the census without much context.

At its best, migration research not only debunks the many myths and misconceptions surrounding migration, but also emphasizes the singularity and uniqueness of individual migrants’ experiences. It is exactly those individual, often poignant stories and snapshots into migrants’ daily lives that were at the center of the creative methods workshop organized by Umut Erel (Lecturer in Sociology, at the Open University) in cooperation with the Migration Museum Project in London. Taking place just a few days before the referendum, and incorporating a breath-taking exhibition on everyday life in Calais’ ‘Jungle’ camp, the workshop opened up a space for collective reflections on the uses and meanings of creative approaches in migration research.

I turned to creative methods in my current research project Immigrant Mothers as Agents of Change to interrogate the multiple and shifting meanings of migration and the urban in migrants’ everyday lives. Conducted within the TRANSFORmIG research framework, my project investigates Polish migrant mothers. Meeting people in a variety of community centers, playgroups, churches, and private homes, I wanted to explore three questions with them: How they make sense of the diversity they encounter on a daily basis in British and German cities, how they do mothering locally and transnationally, and how they navigate various nationalized, classed, and gendered ideologies of motherhood.

A key aim of the research was to find methods that do not assume the importance of migration and the urban in people’s everyday lives. Rather, I leave it to the research participants to determine what is important to them. One of the methods involved asking participants to respond visually to the question: how is it for you to be a mother here [e.g., in Birmingham]? I give the women a white sheet of paper and a bunch of colourful felt-tip pens and, when they are finished with the drawing, we start talking about the images they created.

The images produced in the course of my research project do not exist on their own, but with accompanying narrations that emerged from image elicitation interviews. My analysis holds that the most salient aspect of an image is what its maker intended to communicate: the participants tell me what is in the picture and we discuss its meaning from there.

In order to make these images accessible to wider audiences a website was created on which we could exhibit the collected material. The website‘s largest asset is that it offers a platform for direct inclusion of migrants‘ voices. The image collection both shows immediately the variety of migrant experiences in urban contexts and points to a range of commonalities within and across urban locations.

Creative methods help complicate representations of migration and diversity in that they yield new kinds of narrations about migration experiences in urban and transnational contexts. Not only do migrant mothers bring up future citizens, they also make themselves – through everyday practices, interactions, and observations – citizens of their adopted countries. Developing new ways of thinking about method, migration research conducted with creative methods reveals the power of small things occurring in the everyday. Innovative visual and digital methods for sharing knowledge provide us with new ways of countering anti-migration propaganda, by explaining what it is actually like to be a migrant mother.

More on Methods in Motion

The Methods in Motion blogs are by researchers linked to the Centre for Citizenship, Identities and Governance. The blogs represent their opinions emerging from research in progress, and do not necessarily represent the views of the Research Centre or Open University. You can discover more about Methods in Motion on the CCIG website.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Methods in Motion: Getting on your bike, and looking for answers Creative commons image Icon Garry Knight under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Methods in Motion: Getting on your bike, and looking for answers

Dr Peter Wood, a Visiting Fellow with the Geography Discipline, argues that although methodological choices are often seen as technical decisions, they can actually be key to intellectual creativity.

Article
Methods in Motion: What does Open Methodologies mean? Creative commons image Icon SomeDriftwood under Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Methods in Motion: What does Open Methodologies mean?

A changing society needs changing methods to make sense of itself. Open Methodologies offers a new way of research. Elizabeth Silva explains more.

Article
Methods in Motion: A collection Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Unsplash article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Methods in Motion: A collection

The Methods in Motion project aims to understand how methods enact discriminations and violence, as well as create possibilities for open and inclusive social change. It is a cross-disciplinary research focus of the Open University’s Centre for Citizenship, Identities and Governance (CCIG)

Article
Methods in Motion: Remaking self-help Creative commons image Icon Meg John Barker under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Methods in Motion: Remaking self-help

Dr Meg-John Barker discusses how new ways of thinking can be linked to new forms of investigation

Article
Methods in Motion: The magpie Creative commons image Icon Stefan Berndtsson under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Methods in Motion: The magpie

Edward Wastnidge is trying to make sense of methods - and has a confession to make...

Article

Education & Development 

Practitioner research

How does a researcher collate and analyse information? What are the best methods of investigating/examining a question?

Audio
30 mins
Researching austerity: participatory engagement Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Nikolai Sorokin | Dreamstime.com article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Researching austerity: participatory engagement

Any research that seeks to make positive interventions as well as produce ‘objective’ data, must foster new kinds of dialogue that support and engage those directly involved.

Article

Society, Politics & Law 

Challenge of the Social Sciences

This course focuses on two interlinked issues: the philosophical questions that ----- in social science research, and research methods. Social inquiry attempts to take a scientific approach to explaining the complexity of everyday experiences, but in practice there are many pitfalls. The course reviews common issues that -----, including language, culture, survey methods and the problems of distinguishing between facts and values, understanding and explanation, theory and observation, and induction and deduction. The central tenet is that philosophical thinking and practical research go hand in hand. This material is taken from The Open University Course D820 The Challenge of the Social Sciences.

Audio
1 hr 15 mins
Dawn of the digital census article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Dawn of the digital census

With online returns for the UK's 2011 census opening tomorrow, Dr Ruppert, research fellow with the ESRC Centre for Research on Socio-cultural Change (CRESC), explores the impact of the web on the census

Article