Science, Maths & Technology

Cool Hand Luke

Updated Monday 22nd August 2005

Robert Llewellyn and Dr Jonathan Hare take on Hollywood Science, testing the science that filmgoers take for granted. Here they look at the famous egg eating incident with Paul Newman in the film Cool Hand Luke

Paul Newman Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC

The film is Cool Hand Luke. Our hero is Paul Newman. The task is to undertake the most marvellously mad, mind numbingly pointless bet in movie history: to eat fifty eggs in one hour, without throwing up. But can it be done, or is it yet another case of Hollywood Science?

 

Could you eat fifty eggs? Could anyone? Our backyard biologists Jonathan Hare and Robert Llewellyn are determined to find out.

 

The first step, find out the amount of space the eggs would take up, then see if a person’s stomach can hold that much.

 

So let’s use some simple calculations. If the radius of an egg is about 2.5cm and the volume of an ellipse is:

 

volume of ellipse =
volume of an ellipse Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission

 

 

 

volume of 50 eggs =
volume of 50 eggs Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission

(where m is metres), fifty eggs will be approximately 0.003 metres cubed or 3 litres when chewed.

Can the human stomach hold this many eggs?

And what happens to the eggs as they pass through the digestive system?

Diagram of human digestive system Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission

When we smell food, our mouth responds by producing saliva, and as we eat, the saliva lubricates our food and begins the process of digestion.

The average amount of saliva we can produce in one go is 300ml, and once this saliva has been used up, food becomes dry and difficult to chew and swallow.

Once Paul Newman has eaten a number of eggs, thus using up all of his available saliva, he would have to wait (so he can produce more) or drink something to help the eggs go down. Once chewed and swallowed, food passes down the oesophagus and into the stomach.

The stomach is a J-shaped organ with very active muscles, which expand and contract depending on the amount of food present.

 

Stomach Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission

It’s 25cm long and a trained stomach is capable of holding up to 4 litres of food. When the stomach is empty it contains about 1 litre of liquid.

So Paul Newman’s 3 litres of eggs should just about fit into a very large stomach. But most people’s stomachs could not hold this much.

Once full, the stomach’s nerves sense that it has become stretched and its muscles begin to work so that the food and enzymes mix together.

The gastric gland secretes pepsin, an enzyme that breaks down protein, and hydrochloric acid which kills bacteria.The gastric gland also secretes mucus that protects the walls of the stomach from the acid.

Once broken down the food is a semi-fluid mass which enters the small intestine, and it is here that most of the digestion takes place. At this stage, only the protein has begun to be digested.

Only small amounts of food are released into the 6.5m long small intestine at a time. This means that most of the eggs will remain in the stomach for longer than three and a half hours.

Here, enzymes from the pancreas break down the sugars, fats and the proteins that were not tackled in the stomach.

Towards the end of the small intestine, the tube is lined with millions of cillia, tiny blood rich projections that give the small intestine a huge surface area, ready to absorb the broken down eggs.

Diagram of Cillia and intestinal wall Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission

Now the eggs move into the large intestine. All of the broken down components of the eggs have passed through the walls of the small intestine into the bloodstream. What remains are the insoluble parts, like roughage and water. The large intestine itself doesn’t contribute to digestion, but bacteria that live there create vitamin K and some of the B vitamins.

The eggs will spend up the 24 hours in the large intestine where most of the water is absorbed. The last of the eggs pass out of the anus about 36 hours after being eaten.

Not only will Paul Newman be bunged up for 36 hours after eating his eggs, the amount of hydrogen sulphide gas (stink gas) he would produce would be awful.

So after all of this, what is the likelihood of Paul Newman eating 50 eggs? Not great. He would run out of saliva, and chances are his stomach would not be trained to take four litres of food.

Hollywood Science rating 2/10 Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission
 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

How do ruminants digest? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Adapted from The New Encyclopedia of Mammals, Oxford University Press article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

How do ruminants digest?

A quick introduction to how ruminants break down the plant matter they eat - equally useful as a quick revision aid on ruminants.

Article
Ever Wondered About... Pancakes? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Subbotina | Dreamstime.com article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Ever Wondered About... Pancakes?

To celebrate Shrove Tuesday (Pancake day) take a look at the science and history of the pancake.

Article
Eggs Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Eggs

Ever Wondered About Food takes a look at eggs

Article
Diabetes care Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 2 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Diabetes care

????????????????????????This free course, Diabetes care, is the Chinese version of Living with diabetes which is also available in English.

Free course
5 hrs
Gene testing Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Gene testing

This free course, Gene testing, looks at three different uses of genetic testing: pre-natal diagnosis, childhood testing and adult testing. Such tests provide genetic information in the form of a predictive diagnosis, and as such are described as predictive tests. Pre-natal diagnosis uses techniques such as amniocentesis to test fetuses in the womb. For example, it is commonly offered to women over 35 to test for Down's syndrome. Childhood testing involves testing children for genetic diseases that may not become a problem until they grow up, and adult testing is aimed at people at risk of late-onset disorders, which do not appear until middle age. In addition, we address some of the issues involved in carrier testing, another predictive test. This involves the testing of people from families with a history of genetic disease, to find out who carries the gene, and who therefore might pass the disease onto their children even though they themselves are unaffected. Here the aim is to enable couples to make informed choices about whether or not to have children, and if so whether they might have a genetic disease studies 'proteins'. Starting with a simple analysis of the molecular make up, the course moves on to look at the importance of protein and how they are digested and absorbed.

Free course
4 hrs
What is the genome made of? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

What is the genome made of?

Genomes are composed of DNA, and a knowledge of the structure of DNA is essential to understand how it can function as hereditary material. DNA is remarkable, breathtakingly simple in its structure yet capable of directing all the living processes in a cell, the production of new cells and the development of a fertilized egg to an individual adult. DNA has three key properties: it is relatively stable; its structure suggests an obvious way in which the molecule can be duplicated, or replicated; and it carries a store of vital information that is used in the cell to produce proteins. The first two properties of DNA are analysed in this free course, What is the genome made of?

Free course
4 hrs
Can dogs read their owners' emotions? Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: RobsonMelo article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Can dogs read their owners' emotions?

Does a dog know what you're thinking? Can your dog empathise? It's possible, suggests new research.

Article
Introduction to microscopy Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Introduction to microscopy

This free course provides an introduction to microscopy and the operation of a simple light microscope, of the type found in histology courses and teaching laboratories. It outlines different methods used for preparing and staining tissue sections for microscopy, and explains how different stains can be used to identify particular cells, pathogens and anatomical structures.

Free course
3 hrs
Influenza: A case study Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Influenza: A case study

This free course, Influenza: A case study, explores the biology of influenza, covering a range of topics including: the virus, infection, replication, mutation, immune responses, pathology, surveillance, diagnosis and treatment.

Free course
6 hrs