Society, Politics & Law

Sex, gender and speed

Updated Wednesday 9th September 2009

Professor Kath Woodward considers the issues that are raised by the media's coverage of gender verification tests for female athletes

Sex and gender are in the news again. While in the academy boundaries are blurred and sex as well as gender can be seen as socially constructed and subject to social and cultural inscriptions that shape classification, in sport there remain very clear definitions of female and male with competitions being for women or for men. Things may not be quite so clear, however as is evident in the enormous coverage given to the 800m gold medallist Caster Semenya. She is fast, so fast that other athletes questioned whether she was a woman, leading the IAAF to instigate gender verification tests, albeit in a procedure that, quite wrongly was leaked before the final at the World Athletics Championships in August.

Caster Semenya Creative commons image Icon José Goulão under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license
Caster Semenya

As a sociologist who writes about bodies in sport, I feel fortunate to have been asked to comment, if depressed that many of the media interviews have been prefaced by some reference to Semenya’s ‘masculine’ appearance. It is hardly surprising that the athlete has a lean body with muscles; most athletes do. Bodies are shaped by sporting practices and these practices shape sport, but bodies are gendered and women in sport have to negotiate racialised, heterosexist stereotypes. Semenya’s raised levels of testosterone may tell us more about what happens to the body of an elite athlete than establishing any certainty about gender categories.

The debate, especially as manifest in media coverage, has invoked expert scientific and medical commentary in its path from claims of unfair practice and a body variously described as ‘manly’ and with a ‘strikingly musculature physique’ to sympathy for defiant resistance to the humiliation of gender verification testing and the claims that this very fast woman, must be a man.

Gender testing has a long history in sport, even though compulsory tests were abandoned at the Olympics in 1992. Tests have changed from those based on the embodied features which ‘experts’ can see to DNA and chromosomal tests to the current more complex panoply of procedures that include psychological testing.

Perhaps there is some acknowledgement of the complexity of gender identities and the weakness of a distinction based on the categorisation of human beings into two sexes; intersex and a range of different forms of development mean that many people than we imagine do not conform neatly to the clear genetic and physical criteria that the regulatory bodies of sport deploy.

The very term 'gender verification' suggests that we could get at the truth. A team of experts will find out, but gender is more complex. The current coverage of Semenya's case illustrates how troubling gender is in sport. Images draw upon stereotypes of what constitutes masculinity and femininity in the current case, as in so many in the past. Women athletes have to reassure us of their femininity, through comportment and appearance, even when they, through the body practices of their sport, necessarily have very different bodies from their female non-sporting counterparts.

Public debate is always framed by a moral discourse of 'fair play' that invokes the unfair advantage that men who pass a women might gain in sport, but what is most alarming and distressing about these cases is the humiliation that women undergo in being subjected to 'verification' and the public and expert scrutiny that is reserved for women. The drug testing which has largely replaced the genetic testing in the Olympics could be carried out without a specifically gendered emphasis. Then maybe we could celebrate the achievements of a woman who can run very fast.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Why gender quotas in business and politics are ineffective at overcoming sexism Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Gemphotography | Dreamstime.com article icon

Money & Business 

Why gender quotas in business and politics are ineffective at overcoming sexism

Dr. Owain Smolovic Jones shows how boardroom quotas and all-women shortlists alone cannot change a culture of misogyny.

Article
Can quotas make gender equality happen in politics? Lessons from business Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Artwork by Catherine Pain © The Open University article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Can quotas make gender equality happen in politics? Lessons from business

With more women MPs elected in the British parliament, is it safe to assume that gender qaulity is happening in politics?

Article
Rio 2016: A Caster Semenya reading list Creative commons image Icon Citizen59 under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license video icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Rio 2016: A Caster Semenya reading list

Caster Semenya's 800 metres victory at Rio hasn't been met with universal acclaim, as it reopens the debate over hyperadrogenic atheletes.

Video
10 mins
Why are Olympic athletes copping so much abuse? It all comes down to gender Creative commons image Icon André Zehetbauer under CC-BY-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Why are Olympic athletes copping so much abuse? It all comes down to gender

Why is there so much gender discrimination in the Olympics? Helen Owton explores sexism and misconceptions about gender in sport. 

Article
Gendering refugee experiences Creative commons image Icon James Gordon under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Gendering refugee experiences

More than one million people sought safety in Europe in 2015. This is no small number: Amnesty International have called this  ‘the worst refugee crisis of our era’, paralleled only by the mass movements of people in the Second World War. But what makes a refugee, where do refugees come from, and where do they go to?  

Article
The Rules of the Game Creative commons image Icon Asian FC under CC-BY-2.0 licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

The Rules of the Game

How do governing bodies of sport ensure fair play on and off the pitch? Kath Woodward investigates...

Article
What’s Social about Chasing the Perfect Sporting Body? Creative commons image Icon West Point - The U.S. Military Academy under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

What’s Social about Chasing the Perfect Sporting Body?

Is it possible to push your sporting performance to its maximum potential regardless of social inequalities? Kath Woodward discusses...

Article
No longer about charity: Women's cricket enters the professional era Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: ECB article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

No longer about charity: Women's cricket enters the professional era

As England retains the ashes, and women players finally get professional status, Kath Woodward welcomes a leap forward.

Article
When soldiering gets sexy Creative commons image Icon edwicklicensedfor reuse under CC BY 2.0 under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

When soldiering gets sexy

We explore the militarization of gender equality and sexual difference

Article