Society, Politics & Law

The white mask

Updated Wednesday 16th January 2013

We explore Professor Paul Gilroy’s abiding contribution to our understanding of black identities and music's role in this

Mask Creative commons image Icon kynan taitvia Flickr CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 under Creative-Commons license Paul Gilroy’s abiding contribution to our understanding of black identities is his systematic prising apart of ‘essentialist’ assumptions about race and racism. For many he has become a weathervane for thinking about ourselves ‘from within and without’ and has become a ‘global intellectual’ of race relations along with other expansive thinkers like Amartya Sen and Tariq Ramadan.  

Gilroy’s first books were written as a post-graduate at the Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies at Birmingham University. His self-penned There ain’t no black in the Union Jack and the co-authored Empire strikes back sought to bring to our attention the neglected analysis of the politics of race.  

It was during these studies of the 1970s that Gilroy started to question whether the Marxist analysis of class struggle could explain race exploitation. ‘In dealing with the relationship of race to class it is has been commonplace to recall Stuart Hall’s suggestive remark that the former is the modality in which the latter is lived.'

This relative distancing from Marxism led to Gilroy’s search for new ways of theorising race and is why he has become one of the most quoted of black intellectuals today.

In his critique of essentialism, Gilroy drew on Franz Fanon’s Black Skin, White Masks (1952). To form a politics of black self-determination, Fanon held two principles still cherished by Gilroy – there is no ‘natural solidarity’ based on an African past and black intellectuals need to adapt to modern European culture.’

Fanon thought both black and white were imprisoned by race. ‘The white man is locked in his whiteness. The black man in his blackness. We shall endeavour to determine the tendencies of his double narcissism and the motivations behind it.’ Without such a challenge black people would continue to be captured by and wear a ‘White Mask.’

Gilroy’s critique of essentialism is evident in his piece ‘Jewells Brought from Bondage: Black Music and the Politics of Authenticity’*.  For Gilroy, understanding musical forms is a visceral and gut matter. ‘Thinking about music – a non-representational, non-conceptual form – raises aspects of embodied subjectivity that are not reducible to the cognitive and the ethical.’

Music can be politically inspirational but beguiling too and it is too easy get seduced and reduced by the antiphonal call and response forms of the slave plantation song. ‘The original call is becoming harder to locate.

Rather than search  for the so-called ‘mouldy fig’ caricature of the authentic blues singer,  a stereotype of wishful imagination, Gilroy decries the search for authentic icons as little more than a recourse to a romantic tradition serving a ‘culture of compensation.’) Top of his challenges to such atrophied thinking about black identity is the nostalgia about ‘Afrocentricity.’

In musicological terms such essentialist assumptions are known as the error of ’homology’ where music could be thought to somehow represent a society or culture as having innate and intrinsic qualities.  

In terms of race Gilroy clearly rejects the notion that a musical form can sum up a pure identity in a once-and-for all way. Rather musical genres produced repertoires not fixed canons.  

It is from here that Jo Haynes, in Music, difference and the residue of race, can spread her musical wings because of the constant re-workings of musical repertoires albeit often through the medium of re-worked references to race.

Gilroy’s writing became more expansive and international while teaching at Yale in the United States. In Between camps (2000) there is a appeal for ‘planetary humanism’ to defeat ‘race’ as an organising concept which reproduces oppressive racial hierarchies.  There are echoes of Fanon.

‘Black and white are bonded together by the mechanisms of ‘race’ that estrange them from each other and amputate their common humanity.’)  In After Empire (2004) he found Britain still entranced by a post-Empire ‘melancholia’ but one increasingly  transformed by a new ‘conviviality’ which has emerged because of the relative success of multiculturalism. 

Much social science writing is derivative and predictable – not Gilroy. He has an independent turn of mind and has the ability to surprise the reader as well as affirm.  

In the Black Atlantic, for instance, there is a profound discussion about the concept of diaspora and how much he empathises with the Jewish experience.   Most of all he challenges complacency and simplistic essentialist thinking. Sometimes his work makes for a hard read but it is a good one if you dream of a world rid of racial hierarchy.

*This is a chapter in The Black Atlantic. Modernity and Double Consciousness (1993)

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

History & The Arts 

Understanding musical scores

This free course, Understanding musical scores, provides a general introduction to how to understand a musical score, and insights into what professional musicians do with the notation that these contain. You’ll learn how to connect the notation you see with the music you hear, from short familiar melodies to a full orchestral score.

Free course
12 hrs
An introduction to music research Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: © free course icon Level 3 icon

History & The Arts 

An introduction to music research

In this free course, An introduction to music research, we have gathered together materials to allow you to explore the ways in which music may be researched. After thinking about different kinds of musical knowledge and their relationship with various musical practices (including performance, composition, and listening), you'll be introduced to some of the digital resources and methodologies that inform music research. The next section, which constitutes the main part of the course, explores a variety of different resource types that can be the focus for music research including diaries, composer manuscripts, images, and instruments before the final section introduces you to a contentious area of current scholarship: the relationship between music and politics.

Free course
16 hrs

History & The Arts 

Music and its media

This free course, Music and its media, examines some of the main ways in which music is transmitted. It considers how the means of communicating a particular piece can change over time; and how the appearance and contents of a source can reflect the circumstances in which it is produced. The course focuses on three examples of musical media that allow us to study music of the past: manuscripts of sixteenth-century Belgium, prints of eighteenth-century London, and recordings of twentieth-century America.

Free course
16 hrs
Reception of music in cross-cultural perspective Creative commons image Icon Jesse Kruger under Creative-Commons license free course icon Level 3 icon

History & The Arts 

Reception of music in cross-cultural perspective

Music is created to be performed, in most cases for an audience, whether in a concert hall, at a street fair or through a radio. But how those listeners receive a piece or style of music influences future music production. This free course, Reception of music in cross-cultural perspective, explores how audience reception, changing social situations and technology impact musical performance.

Free course
15 hrs
OpenLearn Live: 7th August 2015 Creative commons image Icon Kirsten Lara Getchell under CC-BY-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OpenLearn Live: 7th August 2015

Rounding off our week of scientific musicians, and tracking free learning across the day.

Article
The Sound and the Fury: Free for All Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

The Sound and the Fury: Free for All

The second episode looks at how music came under state control in the 1930s and serialism took over after the war.

Article
Thinking Allowed - Music and race Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Jupiter Images article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Thinking Allowed - Music and race

The enduring and complex relationship between race and music is the focus of this week's Thinking Allowed.

Article

History & The Arts 

The Italian Cantastorie

Italians are world renowned as passionate people, and their passion feeds through to their music and story telling. This album explores the tradition of the Cantastorie - the Italian Storyteller. Cantastorie Mauro Geraci explains the intricacies of the music, the paintings, the instruments and the drama of the performance. This material is drawn from The Open University course AA317, Words and music.

Audio
40 mins
All the fun of the festival Creative commons image Icon Pooyall under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

All the fun of the festival

From the muddy field variety to town-based folk festivals – it's all the fun of the festival

Article