Forensic psychology
Forensic psychology

This free course is available to start right now. Review the full course description and key learning outcomes and create an account and enrol if you want a free statement of participation.

Free course

Forensic psychology

1.1 Mistaken identification

Although crime dramas focus more and more on the forensic analysis of physical evidence (e.g. DNA), the human element of the story, particularly the evidence provided by victims/witnesses, remains a compelling component.

In real life, eyewitness testimony plays an incredibly important role in police investigations. As eyewitnesses are human, the accuracy and usefulness of the evidence they provide can only be as good as the human mind allows. Understanding the psychology of how the mind works, particularly how we remember, is therefore a crucial component in helping to evaluate and improve police investigations.

Activity 1.1 Eyewitness identification

Allow about 15 minutes

Eyewitness identification evidence is a critical component of many criminal investigations, but how accurate is it?

Psychological research has shown that making even small changes to the way police obtain eyewitness evidence can have a profound effect on its accuracy. Watch ‘Mistaken identification’ and follow the instructions.

Download this video clip.
Skip transcript

Transcript

GRAHAM PIKE
You're about to see video footage of a staged crime. Please watch it carefully.
Do you think you would make a good witness if you were now interviewed by the police? Would you be able to remember everything about the crime? Can you remember what the person was wearing? Can you remember what the person took? Can you remember how many computers were in the office? Did the person have to unlock the door before entering the office?
Although details such as these are important, perhaps the most important information the witness can provide relates to the identity of the perpetrator. As well as describing the appearance of the perpetrator, witnesses are also often asked to asked to identify the perpetrator from an identification parade. Of course, the police first have to find and arrest a suspect before they ask the witness to make an identification, which usually means a gap of 4 to 6 weeks between the crime and the identity parade.
So let's see how good a witness you would be. In a moment we're going to show you a photo lineup. There will be a letter next to each of the photos in the line-up. All you have to do is work out who the perpetrator is and remember their letter.
Like most witnesses, you probably didn't find it that easy to work out what the perpetrator looked like. So let's work out how you did.
Did you pick one of the letters? I'm afraid that if you picked anyone from the identity parade, you made a misidentification. The perpetrator of the crime you saw previously wasn't in the parade, so if you picked out anyone you picked out an innocent suspect.
So if you did identify an innocent suspect - why was that?
Psychological research has pointed to a number of reasons that could explain this. Amongst these are the fact that our memory for unfamiliar faces is very inaccurate. The person you saw commit the crime was unfamiliar to you - you only saw them for a few seconds. It's therefore very hard for you later to identify them, to recognise them.
Secondly, you saw all the faces in the identity parade at the same time - that is, they were presented simultaneously. When you see faces in the identity parade at the same time, what you tend to do is try to pick the best match for the perpetrator, even if that person isn't the perpetrator. So you look amongst all the faces and you pick the one that most resembles the perpetrator, even if it's not them.
Thirdly, it's possible that you picked someone out from the line-up because I told you to. At the beginning of the identity parade, the instruction that was used was a leading question. It suggested to you that the perpetrator was going to be in the parade, because I said "Pick out who it is and remember their number". So maybe the reason you picked someone out was because you were told to.
Psychologists in the police have worked hard in the UK to overcome these problems, so suggestive questions are not used and the faces are shown one at a time to avoid witnesses simply picking the best match. However, it is very hard to overcome the fact that our memories tend to be very inaccurate. Misidentifications can lead to someone being prosecuted for a crime they did not commit. In 2007 DNA evidence finally exonerated Jerry Miller, who had spent 24 years in prison for a rape he did not commit. His conviction was based on evidence from 2 eyewitnesses. Their misidentification led to an innocent person being imprisoned for most of their adult life, whilst the real perpetrator walked free. Jerry Miller's case was the 200th case the US Innocence Project successfully appealed using DNA evidence. Eyewitness identifications played a role in 77% of these wrongful convictions.
End transcript
Copy this transcript to the clipboard
Print this transcript
 
Interactive feature not available in single page view (see it in standard view).

Discussion

Reflect on how you did in the task and think about the implications for how your memory works. Do you think a witness’s memory of the perpetrator’s face should be trusted as evidence?

FPSY_1

Take your learning further

Making the decision to study can be a big step, which is why you'll want a trusted University. The Open University has over 40 years’ experience delivering flexible learning and 170,000 students are studying with us right now. Take a look at all Open University courses.

If you are new to university level study, find out more about the types of qualifications we offer, including our entry level Access courses and Certificates.

Not ready for University study then browse over 900 free courses on OpenLearn and sign up to our newsletter to hear about new free courses as they are released.

Every year, thousands of students decide to study with The Open University. With over 120 qualifications, we’ve got the right course for you.

Request an Open University prospectus