Science, Maths & Technology

A partial history of OU adventures in lego engineering

Updated Friday 7th December 2012

Radio 4's More or Less looked at the force required to crush Lego bricks. Tony Hirst digs through 20 years of Lego at the OU...

When the OU's Dr Ian Johnston took up a challenge from the BBC Radio 4 More or Less programme to calculate how tall can a Lego tower can get before the weight of it crushes the bottom brick, intrepid producer Ruth Alexander might have been surprised to find quite so much Lego at the OU...

The earliest OU Lego activity I came across goes back almost 20 years ago, to the time of the mechatronics course Designing Intelligent Machines. As part of a home experiment kit, students were provided with Lego bricks, some OU produced electronics, and I believe a ping pong ball (does anyone remember what the ping pong ball was for?!) so they could build their own desktop robot.

Almost a decade later, I was part of a small team that put together the Robotics and the Meaning of Life short course (T184 in OU jargon), which included an optional set of home experiment activities based on the Lego Mindstorms Robotics Invention System. Developing T184 meant that we had to play with do educational research around the use of Lego, and also spawned the OU's Robotics Outreach Group that delivered robotics outreach activities to schools across the UK over a five year period.

Revisiting Lego as part of the day job was certainly an eye opening experience. I'd had Lego as a child, though never Lego Technic (aka "technical Lego") but now I was supposed to be working with it. One of the first things I discovered was the geometrical beauty of it, in part through The Art of Lego Design, by Fred Martin, another educator active in promoting Lego based robotics:

"Most people realize that the LEGO brick is not based on a cubic form. The height of the brick is a larger measure than the length and width (assuming the normal viewpoint of studs on the top). But few people know the secret relationship between these dimensions: the vertical unit is precisely 6/5 times the horizontal ones. Put another way, a stack of five LEGO bricks is exactly equal in height as a six-stud LEGO beam is long."

If you also realise that Lego plates are 1/3 the height of the standard Lego block, the informed Lego inventor soon learns how to assemble Lego Technic structures that incorporate vertical and diagonal structures which provide mechanical strength. At the heart of it, is a geometrically inspired mathematics.

I also learned that Lego structures could be used to do multiplications, of speeds and forces, using gear trains. Simple gear trains achieve a multiplication effect in the following way: a large gear, whose teeth are meshed with a smaller gear, turns once; the smaller gear, with less teeth on its circumference, turns more than once. It rotates faster than the larger gear, though it can exert less rotational force ("torque"). This works the other way, too. The small gear turns once, and the large gear turns less than once, though it can exert a greater force. Things get more interesting when we move up to compound gears... Like this simple example:

Lego buggy Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Open University A Lego buggy

(Shh... don't tell anyone... but I managed to sneak out these course notes on gear trains...)

I never did quite manage to build mechanical computer though, unlike this example of a Lego difference engine...

As part of the T184 course materials, we also had to produce construction plans for the robot buggy that students would use for their programming exercises. One way to produce Lego building plans is to construct a model, photograph it, and then take it apart, photographing each step, and the piece(s) you have just removed from the model as you do so. Having captured the deconstruction of the model, reversing the order of the photographs produces the construction plans.

That was too easy though. Which is how I came to discover the world of CAD - Computer Aided Design. CAD packages? For Lego...? For sure - and they let us create images like the following, as well as construction plans:

Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Open University Lego gears

If we'd had time, or bumped the course up to a more traditional 30 point, 300 hour course from it's 10 point/100 hour allocation, who knows? We might even have included a unit on Lego-based computer-aided design.

(The package I used to use - MLCad - looks as if it's still around for Windows computers, with an alternative offering for Mac users. Check out the LDraw site for more details. I also notice there's now an "official" Lego CAD studio available for download too.)

Having built up a considerable amount of expertise in Lego robotics through developing T184, we didn't let it go to waste. TXR120 Engineering: An Active Introduction included a day long hands-on workshop, in which students took on the challenge of programming a robot to search an enclosed tunnel network for a lost teddy bear...

We also spent a lot of time in schools and at family learning events, running hands-on robotics sessions.

Whilst an updated version of T184 continues in the new course Technologies in practice, the Lego activities are no longer included. But fear not - Lego robotics still lives on, in part, in one other OU course: T885 Team Engineering. During the first residential weekend of that course, small teams of students spend a hectic couple of hours building a working model of a robotic amusement park, complete with autonomous robot buggies and automatically triggered amusements.

I'd like to think that if we had a bit longer - maybe a week or two - they could actually build an automated airplane factory...

Whilst the forces experienced by some of the Lego figures on the at times terrifying amusements built by the T885 student teams are often enough to shake some of the rides to pieces, they're not quite large enough to actually crush a Lego brick. I have seen Lego axles twisted and misshapen, though, as a result of some over-ambitious gearing schemes. I've never seen anyone crush a brick though. As to what sorts of forces you'd need to do that, here's Ian...

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

The Tay Bridge Disaster: Aftermath Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: St Andrew's Valentine Collection article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

The Tay Bridge Disaster: Aftermath

The aftermath of the Tay Bridge Disaster, part of the BBC/OU's programme website for Forensic Engineering.

Article
Richard Feynman: bongo playing Nobel laureate Creative commons image Icon Fermilab under Creative-Commons license article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Richard Feynman: bongo playing Nobel laureate

Richard Feynman: theoretical physicist and Nobel laureate, educator, practical joker, bongo player, shameless self-publicist, polymath, or simply, genius; take your pick 

Article
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: photos.com article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

Mike Richards takes a detailed look at the complex world of Internet censorship

Article
The Tay Bridge Disaster: Design of the bridge Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Dundee Central Library article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

The Tay Bridge Disaster: Design of the bridge

About the design of the Tay Bridge, part of the BBC/OU's programme website for Forensic Engineering

Article
Theories in Technology Evaluation Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Theories in Technology Evaluation

This free course, Theories in Technology Evaluation, is devoted to exploring and analysing the theoretical and political nature of evaluation and assessment. It introduces theories and paradigms that play important roles in how we design, conduct and use evaluations and assessments, and deals with the thorny issue of participation in evaluation.

Free course
20 hrs
The last of a disappointing series Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Tom Hewitt article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

The last of a disappointing series

Too late in his run, Lord Broer's final Reith Lecture recognises that not all technological progress is positive, says Tom Hewitt.

Article
DIY tech - just making it up with the Arduino Creative commons image Icon by Randomskk, some rights reserved under Creative-Commons license audio icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

DIY tech - just making it up with the Arduino

Arduino is an exciting, but simple way to get into electronics, as Tony Hirst explains

Audio
5 mins
Superconductivity Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Superconductivity

The fascinating phenomenon of superconductivity and its potential applications has attracted the attention of scientists, engineers and businessmen. Intense research has taken place to discover new superconductors, to understand the physics that underlies the properties of superconductors, and to develop new applications for these materials. In this free course you will read about the history of superconductors, taking a brief look at their properties. You will also learn about modelling the properties of superconductors and the two different types of superconductor that exist today.

Free course
12 hrs
Forensic Engineering: Weigh up the evidence for Tay Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Open2 team article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Forensic Engineering: Weigh up the evidence for Tay

Evaluating the evidence as to why the Tay Bridge collapsed, part of the BBC/OU's programme website for Forensic Engineering

Article