Science, Maths & Technology

Do crowds behave like fluids?

Updated Tuesday 1st August 2006

It used to be believed that crowds behaved like fluids - until Keith Still proved otherwise.

A crowd consists of many individuals each exploiting their best opportunity. Although each of these individuals are doing what’s best for them, they are not aware of what is best for the crowd.

Keith Still was stuck in a queue with 10,000 other people trying to get into a concert and the queue was moving in a very strange way.

Inflatable people in a blow-up crowd [Image: 7-how-7 under CC-BY-NC-ND licence] Creative commons image Icon 7-how-7 via Flickr under Creative-Commons license
Inflatable people in a blow-up crowd [Image: 7-how-7 under CC-BY-NC-ND licence]

"If you imagine an eggtimer where the grains of sand are flowing in the centre, then that’s one type of fluid flow, granular flow where you can really understand this in terms of frictional forces and particles.

Then here I was in the centre of the crowd and I was moving much slower than the edges. So this seemed to be back to front to the standard thought."

Clearly a crowd isn’t fluid. At this point, he really got excited:

"You begin to understand that you’ve found something that is very different from what everybody else has been seeing."

The mathematics needed to be inverted in some way. Keith's research in the last few years has really been to understand the nature of crowd flow as opposed to the nature of granular or fluid flow.

A different type of mathematics needs to be used to solve these sorts of problems. The only way you can really build models of these types of phenomena is to go out in a crowd and walk around. He explains:

"You time yourself, you use metronomes to see if your pace is keeping consistent, you use security cameras, video cameras, use as much material as possible in order to record the event and then you can sit down in the lab afterwards and analyse what it is you’re seeing.

I must have taken thousands and thousands of photographs, many hundreds of hours of video footage. I have a double garage and I can’t get the car into it – that’s the amount of material I have collected!"

After an operation on his back, Keith had to rest for a while for a long time.

"When you lie down and you only have your mind really to experiment with mathematics, you start to look around you and assess things around you in a different way. In the corner of the room was a cobweb just swinging in the wind.

Within the cobweb was a very complex set of movements but I could see in the shadow on the wall a much simpler object which was reduced to just two dimensions.

Suddenly it gave me the idea that if I deconstruct three dimensional objects into series of one or two dimensional properties, I can calculate the maths much easier. I have reduced the problem from many dimensions down into a simple problem of one step only.

If we understand the principles of what we need to do to solve that one step, we can reconstruct that object now by thousands of entities each doing one step at a time and you solve the whole problem. If you get the maths right at the bottom level, everything else works out about it."

His hopes for the future are very simple. By applying simulations, crowds can be made safer and the guidelines can be changed. He says that this has given him fantastic insights into other types of problems.

For example, how the foreign exchange market works, how the phenomenon of business opportunities and how marketing works because that’s crowd behaviour.

"The interesting thing is that you don’t just solve the one problem of how a crowd moves but you open up a new area of mathematics, of large scale interactive systems. This is where science comes into play.

If the information that everybody else is using is inconsistent with the observations you have made, either your observations are wrong, or the rest of the world is wrong."

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

David Milstead: It's the Race for the Pole Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: OU audio icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Audio
10 mins
A prime primer Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

A prime primer

They're astonishingly powerful numbers. Simon Singh introduces the primes.

Article
Mathematical striptease Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Open University video icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Mathematical striptease

Does maths get your knickers in a twist? Watch this video to see how maths can hold the solution to some everyday problems

Video
5 mins
Analysing skid marks Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Analysing skid marks

This free course, Analysing skid marks, is the second in the series of five courses on mathematical modelling. In it you are asked to relate the stages of the mathematical modelling process to a previously formulated mathematical model. This example, that of skid mark produced by vehicle tyres, is typical of accounts of modelling that you may see in books, or produced in the workplace. The aim of this course is to help you to draw out and to clarify mathematical modelling ideas by considering the example. It assumes that you have studied the course Modelling pollution in the Great Lakes.

Free course
4 hrs
Real functions and graphs Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 2 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Real functions and graphs

Sometimes the best way to understand a set of data is to sketch a simple graph. This exercise can reveal hidden trends and meanings not clear from just looking at the numbers. In this free course, real functions and graphs, you will review the various approaches to sketching graphs and learn some more advanced techniques.

Free course
20 hrs
Maths everywhere Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Maths everywhere

This free course, Maths everywhere, explores reasons for studying mathematics, practical applications of mathematical ideas and aims to help you to recognise mathematics when you come across it. It introduces the you to the graphics calculator, and takes you through a series of exercises from the Calculator Book, Tapping into Mathematics With the TI-83 Graphics Calculator. The course ends by asking you to reflect on the process of studying mathematics. In order to complete this free course you will need to have obtained a Texas Instruments TI-83 calculator and the book Tapping into Mathematics With the TI-83 Graphics Calculator (ISBN 0201175479).

Free course
8 hrs
Diary of a data sleuth: Data-scraping the sick bucket Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Mabe123 | Dreamstime.com article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Diary of a data sleuth: Data-scraping the sick bucket

Are more of us getting sick in winter or is it just hype? Our resident data sleuth set out to unpick the stories of winter bugs in the run up to Christmas.

Article
Rounding and estimation Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Rounding and estimation

Scientific calculators are a wonderful invention, but theyre only as good as the people who use them. If you often get an unexpected or ridiculous result when you press the enter button, this free course, Rounding and estimation, is for you. Learn how to do a calculation correctly and get the right answer every time.

Free course
5 hrs
Two can play at that game: When polls collide Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Kaarsten | Dreamstime.com article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Two can play at that game: When polls collide

Can surveys be rigged to give each client the result they want? Or is there some subterfuge at hand in the way the results of polls can be reported? Let this article guide you through the murky world of using opinion polls to make a point.

Article