Skip to content
Society, Politics & Law

Review: Chavs - The Demonization of the Working Class

Updated Wednesday 29th June 2011

John Booth reviews Owen Jones' Chavs: The Demonization of the Working Class and asks how the image of the bulldog breed turned into a narrative of feral children.

Owen Jones has taken on a big job documenting the way most of the citizens of these islands are commonly portrayed. It’s a task long overdue given the changes that have turned "the salt of the earth" into the target of routine abuse by The Sun and Daily Mail, the patronised guests of Jeremy Kyle and the caricatures of Little Britain.

"Chavs" - a 21st century acronym for those of our fellow Britons styled Council Housed And Violent - have become representative of the feckless "underclass". They are those who choose benefits over hard work, who prefer drunkenness, obesity and drug addiction to fitness, who elevate racism above decency and single motherhood above respectable family life.

A car decorated as a 'chavmobile' promoting a record by Goldie Lookin' Chain Creative commons image Icon StarOpal under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license
A 'chavmobile' promotes a Goldie Lookin' Chain record

They are the people locked well outside the communities of Middle England and those above such communities, to many of our politicians, journalists and commentators they are natives of a foreign land.

Owen Jones argues that we are light years from those poor, brave inner-city communities who could take it during the Blitz and who could make it when we were the workshop of the world. Those we see at the cenotaph each year and on Second World War anniversaries, that we venerate for their courage, wisdom and quiet dignity, sprung from the same places that now, we are led to believe, can only produce those lacking in any of these qualities.

Travel to large parts of Britain today and you will see the hollowed-out husk of communities whose inhabitants struggle to survive. Their portrayal, rarely flattering in the good times, has become markedly more nastily caricatured in the decades of dog-eat-dog individualism.

When we briefly honour at Prime Minister’s Questions the dead of our current armed forces, we hear little about those working-class communities who have given many of them life, and to whom their coffins are returned as invisibly as those who come home breathing, but whose maimed lives will never again be the same for themselves or those who love them.

So what has changed, asks Owen Jones? Mainly, he says, the fact that the working class no longer has work.

"The old industrial heartlands contain the highest levels of people without work and dependent on benefits. The root cause is lack of secure jobs to replace the ones that disappeared."

There are some jobs to be had, to be sure, but for fewer than a quarter of those needing them, and they are often unskilled, low-paid and insecure. Very rarely are they the jobs that were at the heart of communities who created things we could sell and often take pride in.

Largely gone, too, are the opportunities to develop skills, earn reasonable money, grow confident, build families - and still have time for community life from watching affordable football to singing Bach, Handel and Mendelsohn in the chapel down the road from the mill.

Margaret Thatcher was strong on preaching "personal responsibility", preferring to attribute her own affluent success to the virtues imbibed in the Grantham shop than to her wealthy marriage. David Cameron, of solid stockbroking stock, follows the same line when he says "social problems are often the consequences of choices people make".

From saying that the less fortunate have only themselves to blame for their situation, it is only a short journey first to rationalising social inequality and then to justifying the benefit cuts now being visited on our "chavs" and their families.

And what of the non-Tory response to this fundamental change in our social and economic circumstances? Jones says: "Only when the BNP was breathing down its neck did New Labour start talking about the working class again." Jones adds:

"If people observe that even Labour holds the less fortunate to be personally responsible for their fate, why should they think any different? No wonder the image of communities teeming with feckless chavs has been so ingrained in recent years."

Jones is more nuanced than this short summary might suggest. He raises important questions as to how Labour was diverted from its traditional working-class constituency to the aspirational "hard-working families" mantra, and into worthy areas of identity politics that largely expunged "class" from its agenda.

But we also need to move a bit deeper than Jones' characterization of "chaz demonization" as traditional class hatred, "the flagrant triumphalism of the rich who, no longer challenged by those below them, instead point and laugh at them".

Sign at a club in Bournemouth proclaiming 'No chavs' Creative commons image Icon kronoc under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license
A 'no chavs' sign at a Bournemouth nightclub

It is that, of course, but British history goes back a bit further than 1979 and the Tory damage to manufacturing and the social fabric of this country he so well describes.

The weary victor of the Second World War, admiring ally of the United States in the Cold War and its "terror" successor, and home to the City of London seeking new ways to assert its influence after the formal disposal of empire, the United Kingdom needed postwar leadership of an order few nations in decline seem able to muster.

Margaret Thatcher was the main beneficiary of the unearned bonus of North Sea energy, but there seems to have been little effort to use that potential for any purposeful national renewal. Trade unionists in engineering led imaginative campaigns for a future not based on arms sales, but they received little support from politicians locked into Cold War orthodoxies.

And, until the crash, there was widespread acceptance among decision makers and opinion formers that financial services were the future.

And what now? The sheer scale of our economic difficulties presided over by a government of Old Etonians bankrolled by their City friends does not of itself guarantee change: Mrs Thatcher pushed up unemployment to over three million and stayed in power.

Cameron and company, which may or may not include the Liberal Democracts, may repeat her electroral success. Will our "chavs" have to scramble forever for poorly-paid work in call centres and supermarkets in a country of growing inequality, separateness and demoralisation?

Jones records the depths of despair, but also sees the chance of a different future for our country and for those who historically have been its working backbone.

“The campaign for good jobs could be the catalyst for far-reaching social change,” he says. “Class politics with a green tinge” would see a commitment to rise to the challenge posed by the housing and environmental crises, reform of the tax system and much else that would make our country a home for all.

This is not just an agenda for the poor, says Jones:

"Most middle-class people cannot afford to go private, and want good, properly funded local schools and hospitals. Polls show that middle-class people support higher taxes on the rich."

Many of our "chavs" have been on the wrong end of bad political leadership all their lives - from the neglect of industrial strategy to divisive housing policy, from the worship of the City to the incestuous self-preoccupation of the political class. As ever more of the relatively comfortable are pushed into lives of not-always-quiet desperation, we shall soon see if Jones’s hope for a new class politics starts bearing fruit.

Chavs: The Demonization of the Working Class, by Owen Jones, is published by Verso.

This article was originally published by John Booth, and openDemocracy.net under a Creative Commons licence (CC-BY-NC). To respond and share your views, join the debate at OpenDemocracy.net.

Find out more

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Discuss: Housing for the working class Creative commons image Icon Betty Longbottom [CC-BY-SA-2.0], via Wikimedia Commons under Creative-Commons license activity icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Discuss: Housing for the working class

Housing has always been a problem for the working class. Fill in our short survey and share your thoughts and memories.

Activity
Languages of class Creative commons image Icon By Chris Jones via Flickr under Creative Commons license under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Languages of class

The Open University's Geoff Andrews explores the revived interest in class

Article
Paul O'Grady's Working Britain: Order your free copy of 'A journal of working class life' Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Paul O'Grady's Working Britain: Order your free copy of 'A journal of working class life'

Order a free booklet exploring different aspects of working class life in Britain through the years.

Article
The working-class garden Creative commons image Icon Sarah R under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

The working-class garden

Thinking Allowed ranges across the history of gardening amongst the lower classes - the role of women, and how programmes like Ground Force threw working class traditions out to make way for all that decking.

Article
Thinking Allowed: Gentrification and division of domestic labour Creative commons image Icon Bob Hall via Flickr under Creative Commons license under Creative-Commons license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Thinking Allowed: Gentrification and division of domestic labour

Dr Melissa Butcher, lecturer in Human Geography at The Open University joins this episode of Thinking Allowed to discuss gentrification and its impact on the working class. 

Article
Language of Comedy - Social class Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Open University video icon

History & The Arts 

Language of Comedy - Social class

The Fast Show writer Charlie Higson discusses how social class and dialects are used as a topic for comedy. 

Video
5 mins
Review: The People: The Rise and Fall of the Working Class 1910-2010 Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: John Murray Publishers article icon

History & The Arts 

Review: The People: The Rise and Fall of the Working Class 1910-2010

Selina Todd's book can take its place alongside EP Thompson and Owen Jones, says Ruth Percy.

Article
Thinking Allowed: Gardens & football Creative commons image Icon Derek Harper under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Thinking Allowed: Gardens & football

Laurie Taylor and guests explore the working class passion for garden, and England's problems on the pitch.

Article
Want to defeat UKIP? Get more working-class people into politics Creative commons image Icon Catherine Pain under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Want to defeat UKIP? Get more working-class people into politics

If the left could get a few more "normal" people on side, perhaps it wouldn’t be left to the reactionary right to shake up the political establishment, writes James Bloodworth.

Article