Working together for children: Stirling
Working together for children: Stirling

This free course is available to start right now. Review the full course description and key learning outcomes and create an account and enrol if you want a free statement of participation.

Free course

Working together for children: Stirling

5 Staying safe, anxieties and risk

In the activity in this section we will initially consider the ways in which children and adults assess and deal with risks. A particular emphasis will be on exploring the degree to which anxieties and perception of risk affect children's lives – the promotion of life skills as well as their healthy development and wellbeing.

After a discussion of what is meant by risk in today's society, we will consider the practice principles underpinning the broad concept of ‘staying safe’. You will be asked to reflect on what we mean by ‘safety’ in terms of both being safe and feeling safe.

From an understanding of the potential difference between being and feeling safe, you will consider how to challenge the assumptions and values that prevent children from being protected from harm. You will also have the opportunity to reflect on how children, parents/carers and practitioners can make considered judgments about how to act to keep children safe.

Activity 6

3 hours 30 minutes

Read the article ‘Encounters with Forest School and Foucault: A Risky Business?’ (Maynard, 2007).

This paper tells the story of an encounter between two early years teachers and two Forest School workers, the growing tensions in their relationships, and how these tensions were resolved. When analysed through a Foucauldian (poststructuralist) lens, the story can be read as a battle between dominant discourses – a battle exacerbated by the outdoor context in which it took place. Exploring the consistency and contradictions between these discourses enabled the teachers to make changes to their practice and to reconstruct their professional subjectivities in a way that more closely addressed their current interests and the requirements of the proposed Foundation Phase for Wales.

Maynard concludes the article by saying that she reads the encounter between the teachers and the Forest School workers not as a personal conflict, but as a battle between two dominant discourses. Identify the key elements of the different discourses discussed.

 

As you watch the following video clip, consider and make notes on these questions:

  1. What are the benefits to the children taking part in this activity?

  2. What do the adults do to help the children assess and manage risk?

  3. How do the adults' instructions and support differ according to the confidence and abilities of the children?

  4. How would you describe the discourse of the workers in Stirling?

Click play to watch the 'Risk' video clip (7 minutes).

Download this video clip.Video player: Risk
Skip transcript: Risk

Transcript: Risk

Lindsay McQuaid
Now this one’s a special one. Oh you’ve got one already. Where did you get your wetsuit from?
Boy
Someone gave it to me.
Woman
Ah good. You just need to go to Jamie and get a tag then.
Boy
Thanks.
Woman
Now see this one. Somebody’s forgot to …
Matthew Brook – Outdoor Officer, Active Stirling
First of all, is everyone wearing one of these spongy suits? Red or blue? Yeh?
Ok, this is your buoyancy aid, that keeps you afloat. Is everyone wearing a pair of shoes on their feet with the shoelaces down up? Good. Is everyone wearing a cag, if they want to wear a cag. I know some people … if you get cold, you tell us you’re going to get cold cos the wind stops that, ok? If you haven’t been on the activities before, what we need to think about are there are some kayaks, you can have a go in some kayaks. There are some canoes and you can have a go in some canoes. There are also two rafts, out there, which you can swim out to.
Two blows of the whistle, that means everyone stops what they’re doing and swims to the shore. That might mean time out, it might mean there’s a shark in the water, ok, or it might mean someone’s a bit injured so we have to pull everyone out. Everyone understand that, that’s the two whistles?
Boy
How will you you, supposed to know there’s a shark?
Speaker
Oh you can see the fins when they swim through the water. You have to look for bubbles as well. And they look people in red buoyancy aids, so you’re ok.
Boy
No! Oh yes!
Matthew
Throughout the summer we work with the Play and Plus services and we do the activity today is water confidence.
The young people get to swim in the water, they get to learn how to canoe, they get to kayak and they just basically have fun. There’s no coaching, there’s no teaching, it’s just general fun.
Lindsay
If you capsize your kayak, you’ve just got to stay nice and relax, can you hear me Rachel? You stay nice and relaxed and you’ll fall out your kayak and these buoyancy aids will make you pop back up again ok? The rest of it I’ll let you work out. Your feet will get quite cold.
[lots of water/voices noise off mic]
Lindsay
Stirling Council play services, they organise the activity, this is their activity and what they do is they provide spaces on it for Plus to use to send along their own staff and their own children.
Shaun’s doing six sessions, so he’s coming every week all summer and the first week we had him he really lacked confidence, not so much the swimming because they’re all used to swimming pools but I think the Loch and it’s dark and it’s big and they adults kind of pushing people in and stuff.
Man
The whole activity is risk managed through risk assessments. All our active Stirling staff are qualified to certain levels, i.e. coaching qualifications for kayaking, canoeing and rafting.
Boy
I’m not going in the water.
Lindsay
You’re not going in the water? We’ll see.
Boy
No.
Woman
We’ll see.
Boy
No.
[more noises off]
Woman
I think when Shaun starts round the edges and then gets a little bit deeper, a little bit deeper, I think he is nervous but I think if you do it that way, then the child keeps trusting you.
Boy
… back to shore. I can’t swim like this.
Lindsay
And it’s baby steps and they are here for, they come several times so you don’t need to do everything in one session and there’s no rush and for some children getting in up to their knees is a big, big achievement for them and that’s kinda their peak in a way but then everyone has different peaks, so that’s ok for some kids, whereas for other kids, jumping off the raft is kinda their peak of what they’re going to do and it’s about finding, you know, the kid’s kind of potential with this sort of thing.
Shaun?
I was trying to keep my hair dry.
[more noises off mic
Boy
I know a good idea.
Woman
You know a good idea, what’s that?
Boy
Water fight!
[lots of splashing noises]
Brendan
Fun, good.
Joanna
Do you not get scared when you go in the middle of the …?
Brendan
No, not really.
Joanna
Are you a good swimmer?
Brendan
Yeh.
Joanna
What do you think about, cos some adults say, oh it’s a bit too dangerous to take children out into the water. What do you think about that?
Brendan
Na because as long as there’s a lot of adults here then you’re alright. But if there’s no adults there then maybe you’re best just stay here.
Joanna
Would you think the children know how to stay safe themselves?
Brendan
Yeh because we’ve have safety briefings on the way up as well. Like people like remember them and be safe and that. So you’ve remembered your rules.
Man
The teachers don’t have the skills the qualifications or the time to take the young people out. They offer, we offer the service to the schools with our qualifications. If we stop running adventure activities the young people are going to get less, or they’re going to miss out. And every child should experience outdoor education.
End transcript: Risk
Copy this transcript to the clipboard
Print this transcript
Risk
Interactive feature not available in single page view (see it in standard view).

Discussion

The Maynard article draws on the work of Foucault, who argued that power is not owned by individuals but, rather, flows through a network of social practices and relationships. Within this definition of power, children and adults are not only governed by others, but also govern themselves and, to a greater or lesser extent, others. Thus, children may be advised what to do by adults, but the degree to which they conform will depend on decisions made by individual children, and will also be influenced by group dynamics.

In the work of Foucault, disciplinary power is seen as related to the use of time and space, as well as to a ‘visible authoritative gaze’ in which individuals are subject to hierarchical observations. Pupils are watched by teachers who are, in turn, watched by head teachers, inspectors (on behalf of the government) and parents.

For Foucault, knowledge is inseparable from power, and is closely related to discourse, or communication, and truth. How we talk shows how we give meaning to the world and what counts as truth. In schools, as in other communities, what counts as truth is constantly changing, and some ways of talking, some discourses, are valued, whilst others are marginalised or silenced. Typically, in school the discourse of the teacher is sanctioned and normalised. Teachers talk more than their pupils and they determine the nature and content of discourse in the classroom. Teachers gain and maintain their authority in the classroom, in part, by controlling aspects of the pupils' discourse; for example, who speaks, when they speak and, to some extent, the subject of the discourse.

In part because of the pressure they feel from higher authorities, the teachers in this research reported that ‘they needed to keep the children safe and to meet curriculum targets’ by setting ‘tight boundaries’ and ensuring a ‘high level of control’ (Maynard, 2007, p.385). By comparison, the Forest School staff felt that their role was to facilitate rather than direct, and to stand back and allow the children to stand on their own feet. A tension existed between the discourses of the two groups of staff.

The teachers, who prioritised curriculum content and child safety, assumed authority over children who they assumed needed to be guided and protected. By comparison, the Forest School workers, who prioritised children's individual independence and freedom, were more likely to position children as strong and able to look after themselves. Teachers emphasised the negative aspects of risk, whilst the Forest School staff stressed the positive benefits to be gained through participating in risky activities.

As in the Forest School, the children in the DVD clip are given some responsibility for the assessment and management of risk. The clip begins with the children being given specialist clothing to wear, including wet suits and buoyancy aids. While this clothing was required, one boy was allowed to opt out of wearing a cagoule. The adults held him responsible for his own wellbeing to the extent that he was given the responsibility of telling the workers if he got cold. The children were told that two blasts on the whistle was a sign to get out of the water. A smaller group were told what to do if their kayak rolled over, but that they ‘would work out the rest as you go on’.

A number of factors may have contributed to the way in which these adults talked with the children, including:

  • the nature of the activity – fun, not coaching or teaching;

  • the experience and training of the adults;

  • the adult to child ratio;

  • a belief that children would choose activities relevant to their confidence and abilities.

KE312_1

Take your learning further

Making the decision to study can be a big step, which is why you'll want a trusted University. The Open University has 50 years’ experience delivering flexible learning and 170,000 students are studying with us right now. Take a look at all Open University courses.

If you are new to university level study, find out more about the types of qualifications we offer, including our entry level Access courses and Certificates.

Not ready for University study then browse over 900 free courses on OpenLearn and sign up to our newsletter to hear about new free courses as they are released.

Every year, thousands of students decide to study with The Open University. With over 120 qualifications, we’ve got the right course for you.

Request an Open University prospectus