2 Leadership checklist
After the discussion of definitions, it’s possible to form a checklist of necessary elements for something to count as leadership:
- There is a tangible practice that can be observed.
- There is a process of influence at work.
- The process affects feelings and intellect.
- Routine ways of thinking, feeling and doing are disrupted.
- The process empowers people to generate alternative ways of thinking, feeling and doing.
- These alternatives, which stretch notions of what was previously considered possible, can become normalised over time through persistence.
Make a note of these six checklist items, because you will be returning to them often as this course – and your own practice – progresses.
Activity 2 Is this leadership?
Watch the following video clip, Leading for a Cause, which is a short programme co-produced by the OU and BBC World Service. The video features the footballer Marcus Rashford, Black Lives Matter organiser Boni Adeliyi and OU academic Michael Ngoasong. As you watch, try to identify an example of each aspect of the leadership practice checklist, making some notes in the box below as you proceed.
As a reminder, the checklist is as follows:
- There is a tangible practice that can be observed.
- There is a process of influence at work.
- The practice affects feelings and intellect.
- Routine ways of thinking, feeling and doing are disrupted.
- The process empowers people to generate alternative ways of thinking, feeling and doing.
- These alternatives, which stretch notions of what was previously considered possible, can become normalised over time through persistence.
Transcript: Video 2 Leading for a cause
Discussion
One example from each checklist item is provided below.
There is a tangible practice that can be observed.
Boni Adeliyi organised a BLM protest, something we can point to and say, yes, that was a real and tangible practice that happened.
There is a process of influence at work.
Marcus Rashford influenced through simple and persistent communication. It also helped that he was closely personally related to the issue of child poverty, meaning that this communication would be accepted as sincere.
The practice affects feelings and intellect.
Boni Adeliyi allowed herself to feel the trauma of the George Floyd murder, and invited others not only to connect to that feeling but to channel it into something positive.
Routine ways of thinking, feeling and doing are disrupted.
Marcus Rashford disrupted notions of who can and can’t be recognised as an activist leader – after all, we are not so accustomed to professional footballers taking such a stand. He used his profile to disrupt the government by embarrassing its senior decision-makers.
The process empowers people to generate alternative ways of thinking, feeling and doing.
What is the evidence that Boni Adeliyi empowered people – or was herself empowered – to generate alternative ways of thinking, feeling and doing? The number of people who attended the protest and her alluding to the work she did on social media before and afterwards provide clues. Prior to these events, a lot of the people who expressed themselves at the protest didn’t think of themselves as campaigners for racial justice. Likewise, Boni developed agency as someone effective in public-facing activism through organising the protest and receiving support.
These alternatives, which stretch notions of what was previously considered possible, can become normalised over time through persistence.
Admittedly it isn’t evident from this video that Marcus Rashford persisted with his work over time. However, our knowledge of Rashford tells us that he did – doggedly, despite ups and downs in his professional career.
Now that you have been introduced to a definition of leadership, you will be introduced to a working definition of race.