2 Creativity and conformity
At this stage in development, children are making over-generalisations with words (e.g. saying ‘feets’ and ‘sheeps’) and with meaning (e.g. calling all four-legged creatures ‘dogs’) and they are also making grammatical over-generalisations. For example, some verbs can appear in both transitive and intransitive constructions, as in ‘the man walked the dog’, ‘The dog walked’, some prefer to appear in the transitive ‘I take the bread’ vs ‘I take’ and some prefer to appear in the intransitive ‘I vanished’ vs ‘I vanished the dog’. Sometimes children use intransitive verbs in transitive constructions and transitive verbs in intransitive constructions (see Table 1). That children are creative with what verb goes with what construction shows us they are experimenting with what constructions can do for them in different communicative contexts. Sometimes their creativity strays beyond what is conventional, and they need to learn to conform with how others use their language.
| Intransitive verbs used in transitive constructions | ||
|---|---|---|
| Utterance | Conventional use | Age |
| ‘Do you want to see us disappear our heads?’ | Do you want to see our heads disappear? | 6 years |
| ‘I don’t want any more grapes; they just cough me’ | I don’t want any more grapes; I’ll cough | 2 years, 8 months |
| Don’t giggle me | I (didn’t) giggle(d) | 3 years |
| Will you climb me up there | Will I climb up there? | 3 years, 2 months |
| Did she bleed it? | Did it bleed? | 3 years, 6 months |
| [They’re nice] enough to wish me that I had one | [they’re nice enough that] I wish I had one | 5 years, 8 months |
| Transitive verbs used in intransitive constructions | ||
| Utterance | Conventional use (because the direct object is missing it is not always obvious from the corpus what the intended referent was, therefore we just use the generic ‘it’ here) | Age |
| ‘Mummy get’ | Mummy get it | 1 year, 11 months |
| ‘Jem have’ | Jem have it | 2 years |
| ‘man take’ | Man take it | 2 years |
| ‘want mummy do’ | ‘want mummy to do it’ | 2 years |