3.3.2 Commenting on work
Reading the work of other writers who are trying the same tasks as you can be invaluable. It will speed up the development of your editorial skills.
Forum assignment activity 2: Reading fellow writers’ work
Now read work by your fellow writers in the forum thread for this activity.
- Use the writing guidelines from the previous previous activity as headings for your comments. These are:
- How was the central character portrayed and was this portrayal clear and interesting?
- What made you think this piece was a story and did you want to read on?
- What were the most, and least, successful aspects of the writing?
- Ensure that you make at least one positive comment and at least one critical comment about each piece.
- Give reasons for your comments, don’t just say ‘I liked this’ or ‘I didn’t like that’.
- We recommend you write at least 150 words when reviewing but you can, and may often want to, write more.
- Check the guidance in the Feedback guidance PDF on giving and receiving review comments.
- If you have time, make comments on more than one story – try three stories; it is better to do a thorough job on three than a less helpful job on more.
Exchanging work not only accelerates your writing and editing development but puts you in the privileged position of having a reader pay attention to your work. They will have a reciprocal interest in the work and they will be better placed (than your husband, wife or aunt) to offer objective feedback.
Forum assignment activity 3: Reading reviews on your own writing
Now read comments on your own work from your fellow writers on the forum thread for this activity.
You will probably have received comments about:
- sentence-level editing, changing word order and using different words
- the portrayal of character, and whether the reader has been able to see the character
- structure and whether the passage works as a story with a beginning, a middle and an end.
Remember the guidance in the Feedback guidance PDF – always pause on any feedback that you receive. Don’t plunge straight into editing and rewriting.
If there are several comments about the same element then it usually means there is an issue there. If you want to resist some suggestions and observations, you may well be right – but make sure your reasoning is sound.