Skip to content
Education & Development

Has media literacy become self-destructive?

Updated Wednesday 17th May 2017

Danah Boyd, founder of Data & Society, asks if American society has become too distrustful of experts

Self-destructive computer Creative commons image Icon 1uffster (Jeanie) under Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license

Anxious about the widespread consumption and spread of propaganda and fake news during [the US Presidential] election cycle, many progressives are calling for an increased commitment to media literacy programs. Others are clamoring for solutions that focus on expert fact-checking and labeling. Both of these approaches are likely to fail — not because they are bad ideas, but because they fail to take into consideration the cultural context of information consumption that we’ve created over the last thirty years. The problem on our hands is a lot bigger than most folks appreciate.

What Are Your Sources?

I remember a casual conversation that I had with a teen girl in the midwest while I was doing research. I knew her school approached sex ed through an abstinence-only education approach, but I don’t remember how the topic of pregnancy came up. What I do remember is her telling me that she and her friends talked a lot about pregnancy and “diseases” she could get through sex. As I probed further, she matter-of-factly explained a variety of “facts” she had heard that were completely inaccurate. You couldn’t get pregnant until you were 16. AIDS spreads through kissing. Etc. I asked her if she’d talked to her doctor about any of this, and she looked me as though I had horns. She explained that she and her friends had done the research themselves, by which she meant that they’d identified websites online that “proved” their beliefs.

For years, that casual conversation has stuck with me as one of the reasons that we needed better Internet-based media literacy. As I detailed in my book It’s Complicated: The Social Lives of Networked Teens, too many students I met were being told that Wikipedia was untrustworthy and were, instead, being encouraged to do research. As a result, the message that many had taken home was to turn to Google and use whatever came up first. They heard that Google was trustworthy and Wikipedia was not.

Understanding what sources to trust is a basic tenet of media literacy education. When educators encourage students to focus on sourcing quality information, they encourage them to critically ask who is publishing the content. Is the venue a respected outlet? What biases might the author have? The underlying assumption in all of this is that there’s universal agreement that major news outlets like the New York Times, scientific journal publications, and experts with advanced degrees are all highly trustworthy.

Think about how this might play out in communities where the “liberal media” is viewed with disdain as an untrustworthy source of information…or in those where science is seen as contradicting the knowledge of religious people…or where degrees are viewed as a weapon of the elite to justify oppression of working people. Needless to say, not everyone agrees on what makes a trusted source.

Students are also encouraged to reflect on economic and political incentives that might bias reporting. Follow the money, they are told. Now watch what happens when they are given a list of names of major power players in the East Coast news media whose names are all clearly Jewish. Welcome to an opening for anti-Semitic ideology.

Empowered Individuals…with Guns

We’ve been telling young people that they are the smartest snowflakes in the world. From the self-esteem movement in the 1980s to the normative logic of contemporary parenting, young people are told that they are lovable and capable and that they should trust their gut to make wise decisions. This sets them up for another great American ideal: personal responsibility.

In the United States, we believe that worthy people lift themselves up by their bootstraps. This is our idea of freedom. What it means in practice is that every individual is supposed to understand finance so well that they can effectively manage their own retirement funds. And every individual is expected to understand their health risks well enough to make their own decisions about insurance. To take away the power of individuals to control their own destiny is viewed as anti-American by so much of this country. You are your own master.

Children are indoctrinated into this cultural logic early, even as their parents restrict their mobility and limit their access to social situations. But when it comes to information, they are taught that they are the sole proprietors of knowledge. All they have to do is “do the research” for themselves and they will know better than anyone what is real.

Combine this with a deep distrust of media sources. If the media is reporting on something, and you don’t trust the media, then it is your responsibility to question their authority, to doubt the information you are being given. If they expend tremendous effort bringing on “experts” to argue that something is false, there must be something there to investigate.

Originally published as part of Points from Data & Society under a CC-BY-SA licence

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Learning to swim in murky seas: Exploitation of the Electorate via Social Media Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: rawpixel article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Learning to swim in murky seas: Exploitation of the Electorate via Social Media

Learn psychological self-defence and start resisting the dark arts of political communication, in Volker Patent’s second article on Brexit and the General Election

Article
Reporting in the fog of an attack Creative commons image Icon Jay Bergesen under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license article icon

History & The Arts 

Reporting in the fog of an attack

As Channel 4 News showed following the Westminster attacks, it can be easy for even the best journalists to slip up covering a fast-moving story. 

Article
Fake news, filter bubbles and Facebook Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: iStock article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Fake news, filter bubbles and Facebook

Who's to blame for the rapid spread of fake news in social media site Facebook?

Article
ICTs: Information Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

ICTs: Information

BBC News 24, Sky News, CNN we live in an era where news has become almost instantaneous. This free course, ICTs: Information, will look at how news is gathered and the technology used for its dissemination. You will also be encouraged to examine how information might be manipulated by questioning its reliability.

Free course
20 hrs
How can scientists fight the tide of Creative commons image Icon NHD-INFO under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

How can scientists fight the tide of "fake news"?

"Fake news" is as much a problem for scientists as politicians. Crispin Maslog calls for an end to propaganda dressed up in lab coats.

Article
Why the Duke of Edinburgh's retirement was a masterclass in media management Creative commons image Icon Bessie Wilde / MidKent College under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license article icon

History & The Arts 

Why the Duke of Edinburgh's retirement was a masterclass in media management

The announcement that Prince Philip was to stand down from public engagements showed that Buckingham Palace has learned how to play the media at its own game.

Article
How Trump tweets Creative commons image Icon Michael Vadon under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license video icon

Society, Politics & Law 

How Trump tweets

Even moving into the White House hasn't stemmed Donald Trump's enthusiastic use of the social network.

Video
5 mins
OpenLearn Live: 13th December 2016 Creative commons image Icon vjamnicky under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license video icon

History & The Arts 

OpenLearn Live: 13th December 2016

The cake that went to court and how social media slowed the size zero trend. Then learning and research from across the day.

Video
Young people making their own media Creative commons image Icon Gage Skidmore - Flickr - CC BY-SA 2.0 under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license article icon

Education & Development 

Young people making their own media

The internet and social media have brought new opportunities for young people to tell their own stories, creating and sharing their own material with the world.

Article