Skip to content
  • Video

The dilemma of tourism and the Irish language, 1983

Updated Tuesday 5th April 2016

Father James McDyer discusses the dilemma of the Glencolmcille holiday village between development, language and culture and the threat of depopulation. Tourism is important for economic development but what impact does it have on local culture and the Irish language?

Transcript: Tourism, crafts and the Irish language?

PAT JESS

Tourism has recently developed as an important aspect of the local economy. Some of the areas characteristics like its remoteness and its traditional culture are precisely what makes it attractive to increasing numbers of visitors. This has brought back an interest in local crafts. The handlooms are back in use to produce wall hangings and other craft items.

Developments like the holiday village in Glencolmcille were boosted by the initiative of Father McDyer. But what effect has increased tourism had on the local culture and language?

 

Tourism was developing as an important aspect of the economy in 1983. An interest in local crafts and handlooms had led to the establishment of Studio Donegal. In Glencolmcille, the holiday village and folk museum, built with local community effort, had opened in 1967. However, Father McDyer summed up the dilemma:

“Now of course it’s a catch 22 question, are you going to lead this into a sort of Indian reservation and have no development at all or are you going to risk the language and the culture by having development?”

Transcript: Father McDyer, 1983: 'The dilemma of development'

FATHER MCDYER

Tourism is particularly obnoxious in obliterating local traditional culture, because tourists come from afar, whether it’s from this country or other countries, and naturally people in an isolated place like this are inclined to ape the tourists in their way of life and in their value and particularly in their mode of speech.

The girls here in charge of our Folk Museum if they meet tourists, as they do, they have to converse in English. So very gradually the Irish spoken residue that we have here is becoming eroded through the development of tourists. Now of course it’s a catch 22 question: are you going to leave this into a sort of an Indian reservation and have no development at all or are you going to risk the language or the culture by having development?

I came down heavily on the side of the latter because I claimed that if you didn’t have development you would soon have no people here at all. But I do think having got a certain amount of development going industrial-wise and tourist-wise then you’ve got to work twice as hard then to try to restore the values that have been lost and especially the language that has been lost.

 

In 1983, positive action was being taken to restore the Irish language and traditions such as described by Michael O'Donnell, ex-shop steward in the Kilcar factory. He was Chairman of the local parish council and active in promoting the Irish culture and language as part of the making of a new synthesis of economy and culture. But this would not be easy. The place of the Irish language as a living part of the synthesis was still to be determined.

Transcript: Michael O'Donnell, 1983: 'The future of the Irish language?'

PRESENTER

The Kilcar community is working hard to restore the Irish language and traditions. Michael O’ Donnell who is shop steward in the Kilcar factory is now leader of the parish council. What is it doing about restoring the language?

MICHAEL O’ DONNELL

Well we attack that on many fronts. First we set up a cultural organisation in the parish which would look after all the aspects and the cultural line. For instance take the language now. We did see that of course the language as the life of Ireland, that is the heart of Ireland in a way, and for that reason we had to do something about a language that appeared to be slipping a bit over the last few years.

PRESENTER

However much the Irish language might be slipping the area itself has been revitalised. Emigration has been stemmed and the local population is increasing for the first time in living memory. The new synthesis of economy and culture’s in the making. There are formidable problems on both fronts, whether the Irish language remains a living part of this synthesis, only time will tell.

[Gaelic singing]

 

Activity: Identifying combinations

We are looking at a local area which is unique - yet many of the characteristics which we've seen can be found elsewhere. What makes Southwest Donegal unique is not the characteristics themselves, but the specific combination of those characteristics.

  • Can you identify some of these combinations?
  • What combinations of characteristics can you identify for your own home place?

 

Now move on to read about A new layer: Agriculture in 2015 – a marginal activity?

 

See all the articles in this series

See all the series in the Change in the West of Ireland collection

This article is part of a collection on the 'Uniqueness, Interdependence, Uneven Development and Change in the West of Ireland'. To find out more about the collection, a good place to start is the introduction, Change in the West of Ireland. 

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?