Activity 6.2 Characteristics of transformative learning experiences
Share three opportunities or barriers to transformative education practice or policy with your peer online learners.
A facilitated bottom up approach to change.
A barrier could be resistance from those with power or an intrinsic fear of change.
Barriers to transformative education practice or policy with peer online learners
lack of spaces for learners to practice what they learn.Engaging in on-going learning and self reflection is bound to bring by systemic barriers in promoting a culture of collaboration, inclusivity and mutual learning.
Helping learners to become aware and critical of their own and their peers assumptions thus broadening their hemisphere.
challenges in creating safe and inclusive educational spaces that support shared curiosity and human compassion in exploring topics that may cause tension.
Navigating the Transformative Current: Opportunities and Barriers in Learning
Opportunities and Barriers to Change
Opportunities for Change:
Increased Engagement and Ownership: When learners are actively involved in shaping their learning experiences and addressing real-world problems, their engagement levels skyrocket. This leads to deeper understanding, greater retention, and a stronger sense of ownership over the outcomes.
Development of "Sustainability Competence": Transformative learning, particularly in the context of sustainability, fosters critical thinking, systems thinking, and problem-solving skills essential for navigating complex environmental and social challenges. This goes beyond mere knowledge acquisition to developing practical competencies for action.
Fostering Interdisciplinary Collaboration: By breaking down disciplinary silos and encouraging holistic thinking, transformative approaches create fertile ground for interdisciplinary collaboration, which is crucial for addressing multifaceted global issues.
Empowerment and Agency: Experiencing the impact of one's actions and contributing to meaningful change can be incredibly empowering, leading to increased self-efficacy and a desire for continued learning and action.
Resilience and Adaptability: By encouraging critical inquiry and challenging assumptions, transformative learning helps individuals develop the mental flexibility and adaptability needed to respond to rapidly changing circumstances and unforeseen challenges.
Barriers to Change:
Resistance to Shifting Paradigms: Traditional educational systems are often deeply entrenched in transmissive models, with a strong emphasis on content delivery and standardized testing. Shifting to a transformative approach requires a fundamental change in mindset from educators, institutions, and even learners, who may be accustomed to passive learning.
Time and Resource Constraints: Designing and implementing participatory, project-based, and critically reflective learning experiences can be more time-consuming and resource-intensive than traditional methods. This includes the need for smaller class sizes, specialized training for educators, and flexible curricula.
Assessment Challenges: Assessing transformative learning outcomes, such as critical thinking, systems thinking, and personal agency, can be more complex than evaluating factual recall. Developing appropriate assessment methods that capture the depth and breadth of transformative learning is a significant challenge.
Institutional Inertia and Bureaucracy: Large educational institutions can be slow to adopt new pedagogical approaches due to bureaucratic structures, established policies, and resistance from stakeholders who prefer the status quo.
Lack of Educator Training and Support: Many educators may not have received training in facilitating transformative learning experiences. Without adequate professional development and ongoing support, implementing such approaches can be daunting.
Fear of the Unknown and Loss of Control: Educators might feel a loss of control when moving from a lecture-based model to a more facilitative role. Learners, too, might initially feel uncomfortable with the ambiguity and open-ended nature of transformative learning, preferring clear instructions and defined outcomes.
Overcoming these barriers requires a concerted effort from all levels of the educational system, from policy-makers to individual educators and learners, to embrace a more dynamic, engaged, and ultimately more effective approach to learning for a sustainable future.
