The standard view of this forum does not always work well with assistive technology. We also provide a simpler view, which still contains all features. Switch to simple view.
Your user profile image

Youssef Bilani Post 1

14 September 2025, 11:55 PM

The Moroccan Paradox: Navigating Tradition and Modernity in Islamic Education

Reflections on Moroccan Islam and Education as Me, I've had the opportunity to reflect on the multifaceted nature of Moroccan Islam and its intersection with education, particularly in the context of combating extremism and fostering tolerance. My observations are informed by the rich history of religious scholarship in Morocco, the contemporary efforts of the monarchy, and the ongoing debates within Moroccan society.

 

Morocco's Legacy as a Center of Islamic Learning Morocco has a profound and enduring legacy as a significant center of Islamic learning, dating back to the founding of al-Qaraouiyine University in Fes in 859 CE . This institution, widely considered the world's first university, has nurtured numerous Muslim luminaries and served as a hub for religious discourse and education across the Islamic world . The historical acceptance of diverse religious currents under the "broad and pluralist umbrella of Moroccan Islam" has contributed to a tradition of pluralism and tolerance, particularly influenced by the Maliki school of jurisprudence . This school's deference to established political authorities and its acceptance of socio-political practices that do not contradict religious obligations have historically fostered a more inclusive religious environment .

 

The Monarchy's Role in Shaping Moroccan Islam The Moroccan monarchy has consistently played a central role in defining and promoting a particular vision of Islam, often intertwining religious authority with political legitimacy . King Mohammed VI, like his predecessors, has actively sought to rejuvenate this rich history, particularly in response to the rise of Islamist extremism . Following the Casablanca bombings in 2003 and subsequent attacks, the monarchy enacted comprehensive security, political, economic, and religious reforms aimed at preventing extremism . This effort has been characterized by the promotion of a distinct "Moroccan Islam," described as moderate, open, and tolerant . A key aspect of this strategy involves the government's increased oversight of religious affairs. This includes placing imams on government payrolls, vetting and training religious leaders, and approving or scripting sermons . Mosques are also subject to regulations regarding their use outside prayer times, and religious expression exceeding government-defined limits can lead to arrest . This centralized control aims to ensure that religious discourse aligns with the monarchy's vision of a moderate Islam and to counter radical ideologies .

 

Educational Reforms and the Mohammed VI Institute Religious education has become a central battleground in Moroccan politics, with ongoing debates about curriculum and pedagogical approaches . The king's directive in 2016 to review school materials aimed to emphasize "Islamic values of tolerance and coexistence with various cultures as well as opening up society to the modern era" . This has led to changes such as reducing the quantity of material, deemphasizing verses related to jihad and war, and incorporating civil rights and environmental topics . A significant initiative in this regard is the Mohammed VI Institute for the Training of Imams, Morchidines and Morchidates, inaugurated in 2015 . This institute trains both male and female religious leaders (morchidine and morchidate) to provide spiritual guidance and promote Moroccan Islamic values . The inclusion of women in this training program is particularly noteworthy, offering an unprecedented opportunity to enhance religious literacy among Moroccan women and empower them as propagators of tolerant Islam . The curriculum at the institute includes Islamic jurisprudence, Quranic sciences, social sciences, philosophy, and vocational studies, aiming to equip religious leaders with a broader understanding and practical skills . The institute also seeks to strengthen Morocco's international standing by educating foreign students from various African and European countries, with the goal of exporting its model of moderate Islam .

 

Challenges and Contested Interpretations Despite these efforts, the concept of "Moroccan Islam" remains contested . While the monarchy promotes it as a unique and tolerant form of Islam, not all Moroccans, particularly Salafis and some Sufis, fully embrace this vision or the monarchy's claims to supreme religious authority . Salafists, who are scriptural literalists, often criticize the Ash'ari theology prevalent in Morocco and view the government's efforts to promote and impose religion as politically self-serving . The government's attempts to control religious affairs have, at times, inadvertently pushed dissenting religious believers to seek guidance from external sources, including the internet, which can further entrench Salafist viewpoints . The promotion of "moderate Sufism" by the government also faces challenges. While Sufi devotion is generally valued, specific practices are sometimes viewed as "decadent innovation" by more orthodox Sunni perspectives . This can alienate both Salafis, who have little interest in Sufi practices, and independent Sufi practitioners, who may perceive the government's version as watered down . Furthermore, while the monarchy promotes religious ecumenism and tolerance, conversion and proselytization remain illegal in Morocco, and native Moroccan Christians often live in fear . This highlights a tension between the espoused ideals of tolerance and the practical limitations on religious freedom, particularly for Moroccans themselves .

 

Personal Reflections and the Path Forward From my perspective as a young Muslim in Morocco, these discussions are highly relevant. The emphasis on education as a tool to confront prejudice and prevent discrimination, as highlighted in the roundtable discussion at the American Legation in Tangier, resonates deeply . The idea that prejudice, while perhaps inherent, can be overcome through interaction and education is a powerful one . The efforts to modernize religious education and promote a tolerant, inclusive Islam are commendable. However, the success of these initiatives hinges on effective implementation and genuine buy-in from all segments of society. The challenges of bureaucratic mismanagement and the varying quality of education across different regions and socio-economic strata need to be addressed . Ultimately, for Moroccan Islam to truly become a unifying force and a compelling alternative to extremism, it must be perceived as authentic and genuinely representative of the diverse beliefs within Moroccan society, rather than solely as a tool for political legitimacy. Continued dialogue, critical self-reflection, and a commitment to human rights and religious freedom for all, regardless of their beliefs, will be crucial in shaping a future where tolerance and understanding prevail.