The standard view of this forum does not always work well with assistive technology. We also provide a simpler view, which still contains all features. Switch to simple view.
Irene Stewart and son

IRENE Stewart Post 1

2 June 2018, 4:44 PM

Reflection on Buildiing Open Community

I created a blog post reflection on feeling marginized and lurking ;) I hope it is okay to post a link as it turned out a bit long.

Day 2 – Reflecting on Building an Open Community 

https://lgcoffeewfourcremes.wordpress.com/2018/06/02/day-2-reflecting-on-building-an-open-community/

ruth Lindsey-Armstrong Post 2 in reply to 1

2 June 2018, 7:47 PM

Hi Irene, 

I couldn't open your blog post, but am interested in the role of lurking in online education.

I am completing my doctorate in education entirely online, just as Jenny is, however I am doing it through Athabasca university in Canada. Having all of our classes online means the are lots of discussion forums. While most instructors build in a participation requirement the are always a couple of students who do not engage. Our cohort is small, there is only 7 of us so when one is missing (perhaps lurking) we lose out on their valuable input. 

We had a discussion about it but the lurkers often choose not to engage even in that. 

Ruth


Adam Weissengruber Post 3 in reply to 2

2 June 2018, 8:19 PM

Link

Susan Jones Post 4 in reply to 3

2 June 2018, 9:18 PM

Thanks :)   

ruth Lindsey-Armstrong Post 6 in reply to 2

3 June 2018, 1:03 AM

I feel like I need to expand upon my post as I agree that "lurking" has negative connotations but can actually be effective for those who are feeling out topics. I get that. A learner in my program is of a particular cultural group and I would be interested to know her perspective based on her culture, however she chooses not to participate in any of the discussions so we don't get to hear her knowledge and experiences.

Your blog site is lovely. I understand your perspective, faculty work in many places in my college beyond the classrooms and often are overlooked. Is there a way to be included in the discussion? I think so. Recently our faculty association was formed and folks from the library (many with teaching backgrounds) have asked to join. I believe they should be included as they bring a variety of experiences into the forums. Is there a similar opportunity in your workplace?

ruth

Marvin Patton Post 5 in reply to 1

2 June 2018, 9:41 PM Edited by the author on 2 June 2018, 9:42 PM

Hey, Irene!

Everybody matters! I'm glad you're reaching out and networking with people beyond your local institution.

I'm an adjunct instructor of Child Development for a community college and I'm the only man in our small department.  I sometimes feel marginalized, like some kind of outsider.  I don't know that there's an awkward gender dynamic (although that's what I suspect), or whatever other social factors may be at work.  I'm a bit of an introvert, so my often reserved demeanor may also be involved.

But recently, I'm finding great satisfaction and rejuvenation by forging relationships outside of the college.  We're talking about Communities of Practice today (and/or Communities of Interest, as Leanne clarified).  I'm connecting with new people and learning about online course design and open education.  I've never done any blogging--but I'm inspired by yours!  I might even venture into blogging as another tool for teaching.

Just as one new friend to another--I agree with Jenni.  Don't call yourself a "lurker"--that sounds too creepy and voyeuristic!  It's also somewhat diminishing--as if your contributions are superfluous or irrelevant. At the very least, you're an observer; and even more, you're a colleague!  You're posting a blog, which certainly promotes our conversation.

Irene's Life Matters!

Laura Killam Post 7 in reply to 1

3 June 2018, 1:39 AM

Hello, 

I wanted to comment on the blog but didn't see the option. It is difficult feeling like the "other." While I don't completely understand where you are coming from I can empathize. I teach a university program in a college setting. Until recently, it always felt like we are the "other" but at least there is a group of us. The union often doesn't understand our needs, and until our Hub was formed we could never attend PD because our calendar was different than everyone else's. 

Things are getting better as we reach out and engage more with faculty in other programs. Even though I don't teach the same things, I often find commonalities with educators from K to College and support personnel. We may not do the same things but we work inside the same structures. 

The open community is made up of a lot of non-teachers. In fact, at OE Global there were very few faculty members there. At CC Global it seemed to be mostly librarians. I think you will find lots of opportunities to fit in, even with the teacher types like me ;)


Laura