1.4 Are Excellence and Equity Mutually Compatible?
It is important to note that EDIA is not universally accepted as desirable, nor is it a politically neutral concept. While many institutions have embraced EDIA as a means of improving research, its role within academia and research systems remains contested, with ongoing debate about its rationale, implementation and implications for research practice (Dewidar, Elmestekawy and Welch, 2022) .
A central tenet of this course is that EDIA can help researchers think differently about research quality. Much of the contemporary EDIA agenda is underpinned by the idea that greater attention to participation, representation, inclusion and accessibility can strengthen research cultures, enhance the quality of evidence, and improve the relevance and impact of research. This view is reflected in a growing body of literature linking equity, diversity and inclusion to academic and organisational excellence (Wedekind et al., 2021).
Debates are often less about whether fairness matters and more about how far EDIA considerations should influence research priorities, methods, funding decisions and evaluations of excellence. While there is broad support for reducing barriers to participation in research, there remains disagreement about the appropriate balance between social objectives and traditional academic values such as autonomy, objectivity and merit-based assessment (Fogarty & Scott, 2025).
This table outlines some of the contrasting perspectives that characterise debates about EDIA in research:
| Debate | Pro-EDIA Position | Critical Position |
| Excellence through diversity vs. Excellence through merit | Diverse teams produce more innovative, creative and robust research because they bring different experiences and perspectives | Research quality should be judged solely on intellectual merit and methodological rigour; diversity objectives should not influence assessments of excellence |
| Standpoint knowledge vs. Objectivity | Researchers' social positions shape knowledge production; diversity helps reveal blind spots and neglected questions | Knowledge claims should be evaluated independently of the researcher's identity and according to universal standards of evidence |
| Social Responsibility vs. Academic neutrality | Research should actively address inequalities and ensure benefits are shared across society | Research priorities should be determined by scholarly and scientific considerations rather than social or political objectives |
| Institutional intervention vs. Academic freedom | EDIA policies are needed to remove structural barriers and create fairer opportunities | Mandatory EDIA requirements may constrain academic freedom and introduce ideological expectations into research |
These debates are important to acknowledge because, as the table illustrates, EDIA is not an uncontested concept. An awareness of these different perspectives enables a more informed and critical engagement with the subject.
We are not asking you to take a particular position on whether equity and excellence are compatible. Instead, it is an invite to engage with the arguments, evidence and assumptions that underpin different perspectives on the relationship between them. Whatever your view, there is broad agreement that social science researchers are not detached observers of the world they study. We all bring experiences, assumptions and blind spots to our work. The challenge, therefore, is not simply to decide whether equity and excellence are compatible, but to think critically about how research is conducted, whose perspectives shape it, and how decisions influence the knowledge that is ultimately produced.
As you work through the coming units, you will see that embedding EDIA in research practice is rarely straightforward. It often reveals tensions, presents challenges and requires difficult trade-offs. There are seldom simple, comfortable or perfect solutions. Instead, the task is to approach these complexities critically and make thoughtful decisions that are appropriate to the research context.


